Top 10 Brooklyn Real Estate Listings: A Standalone in Caton Park, a Bungalow in Bay Ridge

The most popular listings on Brownstoner this week include a co-op in Boerum Hill, a brownstone in Bed Stuy and, outside of Brooklyn, a standalone in Newburgh, N.Y.

Bed Stuy was popular this week with multiple listings in the top 10. The least expensive on the list is the brick house in Newburgh at $800,000 and the most expensive is a Carroll Gardens brownstone at $8.75 million.

Which would you choose?

10. This Park Slope brownstone has an interesting mix of historic and contemporary details ranging from mantels and a pier mirror to parking and solar panels.

99 Lincoln Place
Price: $4.25 million
Area: Park Slope
Broker: Corcoran (Katie A. Feola)
Park Slope Neo-Grec With Parking, Solar Panels, Chicken Coop Asks $4.25 Million
See it here ->

9. In the Prospect Lefferts Gardens Historic District, this circa 1900 barrel-front row house has plenty of original details, including carved wood mantels with original tile, a pier mirror, window seats, and dining room with wainscoting and coffered ceiling.

73 Sterling Street
Price: $1.495 million
Area: Prospect Lefferts Gardens
Broker: Douglas Elliman (Peter Perez)
Bay Ridge Bungalow With Garage and Three Other Open Houses to See, Starting at $1.1 Million
See it here ->

8. Likely dating from the 1920s, this bungalow row house with front porch and detached garage in Bay Ridge has plenty of original details and appears to be in good condition.

348 81st Street
Price: $1.25 million
Area: Bay Ridge
Broker: Corcoran (Gina and Kevin Bartnik)
Bay Ridge Bungalow With Garage and Three Other Open Houses to See, Starting at $1.1 Million
See it here ->

7. When this early 20th century single-family in the Flatbush micro-nabe of Caton Park was on the market in 2019 it seemed to have everything, including well-kept original details, lots of bedroom space, a bathroom on every floor, central air and a garage.

57 Marlborough Road
Price: $3.495 million
Area: Caton Park
Broker: Compass (Steve Halpern)
After a Makeover, a Caton Park Standalone Is Back on the Market and Asking $3.495 Million
See it here ->

6. Only two floors of this Carroll Gardens brownstone are depicted in the listing, but there are enough details to entice, including plasterwork, moldings and a marble mantel.

393 Clinton Street
Price: $8.75 million
Area: Carroll Gardens
Broker: Brown Harris Stevens (Brian Lehner)
Carroll Gardens Brownstone With Plasterwork, Wood Burning Fireplace Asks $8.75 Million
See it here ->

5. On the fourth floor of Boerum Hill’s Ex Lax building, this particular unit’s most striking feature is its 14-foot-high vaulted, arched ceiling with cork panels.

423 Atlantic Avenue #4M
Price: $1.85 million
Area: Boerum Hill
Broker: Compass (Jodie Garay, Brian Earley)
Boerum Hill’s Ex Lax Building Loft With Two Bedrooms, Vaulted Cork Ceiling Asks $1.85 Million
See it here ->

4. In Bed Stuy’s Bedford Historic Historic District, this legal two-family, a four-story 1880s Renaissance Revival brownstone, has a one-bedroom apartment with its own entrance at the rear of the garden floor.

1 Arlington Place
Price: $3.125 million
Area: Bed Stuy
Broker: Compass (Morgan Munsey, Perri DeFino)
A Bed Stuy Renaissance Revival Brownstone and Three More to See, Starting at $1.099 Million
See it here ->

3. In the architecturally rich city of Newburgh, this circa 1860s brick dwelling certainly has curb appeal, a spacious interior and comes with the bonus of a separate studio space.

225 Montgomery Street
Price: $800,000
Area: Newburgh, N.Y.
Broker: Berkshire Hathaway Hudson Valley Properties (William D. Spinelli, Jr.)
A Newburgh Italianate With Curb Appeal and Studio Space, Yours for $800K
See it here ->

2. This late 19th century Bed Stuy brownstone has well preserved details, including the original stair, white-painted woodwork, striking carved wood mantels with colorful original tile and built-ins in the garden-floor kitchen.

603 Macon Street
Price: $1.8 million
Area: Bed Stuy
Broker: Corcoran (Keith Mack)
A Bed Stuy Brownstone With Handsome Mantels and Three Others to See, Starting at $659K
See it here ->

1. In Bed Stuy’s Stuyvesant Heights Historic District, a grand corner Italianate built in the early 1870s has its original newel post and staircase, ceiling medallions, shutters, pocket doors and a marble mantels.

267 Macon Street
Price: $2.15 million
Area: Bed Stuy
Broker: Corcoran (Omari Toomer, Peter-Charles Bright)
A Bed Stuy Brownstone With Handsome Mantels and Three Others to See, Starting at $659K
See it here ->

Related Stories

• Find Your Dream Home in Brooklyn and Beyond With the New Brownstoner Real Estate
• Top 10 Brooklyn Real Estate Listings: A Boerum Hill Co-op, a Carroll Gardens Brownstone
• Top 10 Brooklyn Real Estate Listings: A Bed Stuy Brownstone, a Park Slope Co-op

Email tips@brownstoner.com with further comments, questions or tips. Follow Brownstoner on Twitter and Instagram, and like us on Facebook.