Building of the Day: 636 Pacific Street
The BOTD is a no-frills look at interesting structures of all types and from all neighborhoods. There will be old, new, important, forgotten, public, private, good and bad. Whatever strikes our fancy. We hope you enjoy. Address: 636 Pacific Street, near 6th Avenue Name: Former Allied Storage Building, now Atlantic Arts Building Neighborhood: Prospect Heights…
The BOTD is a no-frills look at interesting structures of all types and from all neighborhoods. There will be old, new, important, forgotten, public, private, good and bad. Whatever strikes our fancy. We hope you enjoy.
Address: 636 Pacific Street, near 6th Avenue
Name: Former Allied Storage Building, now Atlantic Arts Building
Neighborhood: Prospect Heights
Year Built: 1924
Architectural Style: Italian Renaissance Revival, morphing into early Art Deco
Architect: Chep Kingsley
Landmarked: No
This was built as the Allied Storage Building back in 1924. It was designed by Chicago architect Chep Kingsley, and was lauded by a storage industry magazine of its day, as the most beautiful and dignified storage building built in New York, and a complement to the new Williamsburg Savings Bank going up nearby.
Self storage is a recent phenomenon of today’s consumer society, but in the 1920’s, only the rich could afford storage, and this building certainly looked quite elegant with its profusion of colorful cobalt and white glazed terra-cotta trim, and classical detail.
There is an Italian Della Robbia style influence to the blue lozenges, as well as a clear early Deco influence in other motifs. Polychrome terra-cotta of this sort is a staple of early Art Deco architecfuture, coming out of the Art Nouveau tradition, and proceeding into the more familiar angular lines of later Art Deco.
The building was owned by the same family until they sold it to the developers who turned it into much hyped loft-style condos in 2002. The developers renamed it the Atlantic Arts Building, although now it will be forever known as Daniel Goldstein’s Building.
That is, until it’s torn down, which could happen at any time. Had this building been anywhere else, it would easily have been eligible for landmarking, as it is a rare example of Kingsley’s work in NY, as well as for its intrinsic beauty on its own, especially with the wealth of terra-cotta in the colors, materials and motifs here.
The details are in excellent shape, and it is a rare piece of commercial architecture of this type and from this era. Wastefully, it will soon be rubble. I hope the terra-cotta is salvagable. That, and pictures will be all that is left.
[Photos by Suzanne Spellen]
Blowfish;
No, I haven’t noticed that. I have noticed that you serve as my personal hall monitor. Good to know I’m lurking in your head.
It has been pointed out to me by the estimable Christopher Gray of the New York Times, that George S. Kingsley was the architect of this building. I guess Chep was either a nickname, or his second cousin, and my source got it wrong. George S. was responsible for the Reebie Storage Building in Chicago, which is a landmark, and he also designed a couple of storage facilities on the west side of Manhattan, specifically at 82nd and Amsterdam, and 134th and Riverside. Both have prolific terra-cotta trim.
Thank you, Mr. Gray!
Benson, have you ever noticed how many people respond to your comments by referring to the pot/kettle adage? A lot of different people.
WBer, I looked for some period photos, but couldn’t find any. I would imagine the storage industry magazine posted one, but that, too, is unavailable to me at this time.
“And for someone who lives in one to say he finds this building ugly, well pot, meet kettle – except, of course, 636 Pacific had way nicer architectural details.”
Golly gee, Babs, that was such a mean thing to say. Oh, I’m so hurt, I’m so hurt.
Quite honestly, I find (found) this building not terribly different-looking from those Shaya Boymelgreen-built City View Gardens condos on 2nd and 3rd Sts in Park Slope. And for someone who lives in one to say he finds this building ugly, well pot, meet kettle – except, of course, 636 Pacific had way nicer architectural details.
A beautiful. renovated building, now a pile of rubble. Thanks for posting that quote, novangelus- it said everything.
Yay! The final vestige of Dan “Sellout” Goldstein is soon to be gone. Good riddance!
Architecturally, this is no gem. I’m particularly thrown off by those terra-cotta spandrel panels that read as windows from a distance. They make the whole facade seem unordered.
But I would love to see a historic photo before passing final judgement – without the HVAC vents and with its original windows (and openings – were there window openings?).