Moving Forward
If you’re a troll or a spammer, you better try to get your last licks in now, because by Monday, the guest commenting function will be a thing of the past on Brownstoner. If you haven’t signed up for a user account yet, please try to do so in the next couple of days. (If…
If you’re a troll or a spammer, you better try to get your last licks in now, because by Monday, the guest commenting function will be a thing of the past on Brownstoner. If you haven’t signed up for a user account yet, please try to do so in the next couple of days. (If you don’t receive your verification email within a couple of minutes, just email us and we’ll verify you by hand.) If you already have a user account and voted for the elimination of guest commenting, please put your money where your mouth is and make an effort to get involved in discussions. Another to remember is that you are still anonymous when you comment with a username: Just pick a silly name like Cobble Hill Guy and stick with it; no other readers will be able to see your email address or know who you really are. Our hope and expectation is that the improved quality of the threadsalong with our ability to boot anyone who steps out of boundswill more than make up for any decline in the quantity of comments.
We know that there are a lot of long-time readers out there who’ve gradually been moving to the sidelines of the discussions as they’ve grown nastier and more inane, and hopefully they will take this as an opportunity to re-engage and take the sense of community back to its roots where we can have meaningful, useful discussions about real estate, architecture and the many issues that confront the borough and its neighborhoods as the inevitable wheels of change continue to turn.
There are going to be a number of new features coming to the site in the next few months, the use of which will also be enhanced by having a user account. The first of these, launching next week, involves a group effort at building a comprehensive restaurant guide for the borough. (Having a username is particularly useful because other readers can come to trust, or distrust, you opinions about restaurants.) Other features down the pipe include map-based mobile access of the Brownstoner archives, neighborhood emails and some new service-oriented improvements in the architect and contractor spaces.
Actually, the comments on curbed are lightyears ahead of the typical posts on this site.
What’s paradoxical about this is that the registered users are typically the ones who drag the discussions down into the muck. So, I fail to see the rationale behind this move.
Odd to see people like bxgirl and others who regularly call people names complaining about comments being nasty. There’s no logic…
I really wish I had a job. 🙂
@4:57 yep the post was pulled.
@ 4:11 comment
Did they really pull a post out? Wow.. Anyone have any cached or reference to that post?
I would love to read what the comments had to say
Mr. B. care to give an input as to why that post was yanked?
“It’ll be so dumb that even the handful of commenters with names whose comments are informative will stop posting”
I really hope not, 4:31. but if you look at the site lately, it’s been more and more guests and nastier and nastier. A lot of regulars have stopped posting over the last few years and they were people who had a great deal to contribute. A lot of them post as guest but it all gets lost in the chaos. I really don’t thing its a business decision in the sense you mean. Without the comments, which indicate hits and interest, a blog isn’t a blog.
speaking of 13 year olds leaving dumb and uninformative comments, check out my new username. hee hee hee!
ditto what 4:27 said. That’s the position of all the smart and reasonable people I know about posting on blogs – never giving an email address. Which is why you will lose the reasonable people and descend into irrelevancy.
What 4:11 said. What’s up with that, Mr. Brownstoner?