[nggallery id=”27585″ template=galleryview]

Here are some very cool before and after shots of a renovation of a South Portland Avenue brownstone that took place in 2007. The architect was Field Lines Architecture, an Lower East Side-based duo with clearly modern leanings. We have to admit to mixed feelings about the whole thing: On the one hand, the finished product looks really amazing, what modern architecture should be; on the other, the intact interior of a brownstone on the definitive brownstone block in the city was lost in the process. At least there are no Fedders boxes! Update: The architects just sent in another view that shows how they did in fact maintain original details where they could. Great to see that our fears were misfounded! “We at Field Lines believe that the real magic occurs when palimpsest of the past are not erased but rather incorporate as unique opportunities for design,” they wrote. Check out the new image on the jump.

South-Portland-Interior-0109.jpg


What's Your Take? Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

  1. Ypu’ve all seen the story about ex-Merrill chief Thain’s $1.2MM office makeover??

    Here’s the furniture list…..

    Area Rug $87,784
    Mahogany Pedestal Table $25,713
    19th Century Credenza $68,179
    Pendant Light Furniture $19,751
    4 Pairs of Curtains $28,091
    Pair of Guest Chairs $87,784
    George IV Chair $18,468
    6 Wall Sconces $2,741
    Parchment Waste Can $1,405
    Roman Shade Fabric $10,967
    Roman Shades $7,315
    Coffee Table $5,852
    Commode on Legs $35,115

  2. Traditionalmod…Missed the opportunity to comment early on, but couldn’t have said it better than you.

    “..really good details IF a house has them. Many houses here don’t. Also the degree to which they’re historic and special can be very little. A bit of molding and maybe one fireplace doesn’t count as a historic interior worth preserving in my book. If that’s all a place has people should feel free to do whatever they want with the interior…”

    I’d add one thing however. Some of the “restorations” Sam refers to are total garbage. I’m sorry, but you don’t get a preservation award for adding some fake brass ceiling fans and switchplates etc. etc., which is what most PS “restorations” have. And if you’re not really “restoring”, you’re not restoring.

  3. ‘I cant find this project on the architect’s seizure-inducing site. What is it under?’

    I gave up! I’m still blinking my eyes to get them to adjust again. And when I close them for a long time, I still see white lines.

    Furniture one step above Ikea is better than furniture one step below Ikea!

1 2 3 4 5 7