In Brooklyn, Yelp Reviewers Favor Pizza and Cheap Eats Over High-End Fare

Composite photo via Yelp


    The people have spoken, and it turns out their favorite Brooklyn eateries range far afield from Michelin and Zagat’s top picks.

    Using a complex mathematical technique, Yelp has calculated Brooklyn’s top 100 restaurants, taking into account each eatery’s star ratings and number of reviews.

    The highest-ranked restaurant, with 136 reviews and four-and-a-half stars, is the Coney Shack, a two-year-old Coney Island–based food truck that serves up Vendy Award–winning hot dogs and tacos.

    In second place is another underdog, Bay Ridge’s The Family Store, a small market and takeout counter with only 65 reviews but all five stars for its special take on traditional Middle Eastern cuisine.

    Best Brooklyn Restaurants 2015

    Coney Shack. Photo by Chelsey C. via Yelp

    In terms of neighborhoods, the known foodie havens ranked predictably high, with Williamsburg landing 28 markets, cafes and sit-down joints on the list, the most of any neighborhood. Next up were the combined results of Park Slope and South Slope, for a total of 12 restaurants. Eight Crown Heights restaurants made the list, Carroll Gardens and Bed Stuy tied with five each, and Bushwick placed a strikingly low four.

    It is notable, however, that the list hardly adheres to what most consider to be neighborhoods’ formal boundaries.

    Brooklyn's Best Restaurants

    Nargis Cafe. Photo by Dmitry S. via Yelp

    An additional 19 neighborhoods made the list, placing one, two or three eateries each. Of these, not a single spot made the list from Brooklyn Heights, Downtown Brooklyn, Ditmas Park, or the majority of southern and eastern Brooklyn.

    Some surprises came with Yelpers’ apparent knowledge, and appreciation for, the borough’s under-the-radar locales, like Ba Xuyen, a Vietnamese sandwich joint in Borough Park (Sunset Park, really) with 422 reviews, and an Uzbek cafe in what the list sites as Gravesend, but is really Sheepshead Bay.

    Moderate or cheaply priced pizza and Italian food are by far the most prominent cuisines here, while there is a surprising lack of diners or classic foodie must-haves. Indeed, neither Peter Luger’s nor Grimaldi’s made the list — but hey, they don’t need the hype.

    Brooklyn's Best Restaurants

    Ba Xuyen. Photo by Dave K. via Yelp

    Related Stories
    Beloved Bronx Mexican Eatery El Atoradero Reopens in Prospect Heights Tonight
    Michelin Adds Two Brooklyn Restaurants to Its List of Starred Eateries
    Here’s How Brooklyn Restaurants Fared in the 2016 Zagat Survey

    Email with further comments, questions or tips. Follow Brownstoner on Twitter and Instagram, and like us on Facebook.

    Brooklyn in Your Inbox

    * indicates required

    What's Happening