1163 new york avenue 2

This may be the first flip we’ve seen in East Flatbush, and likely the start of many more to come. For a flip, it’s decent looking, we think. The exterior has a lot of charm, and there is central air and a restored two-car garage.

We could see this appealing to a lot of buyers priced out of areas closer to Manhattan who need more space and something in move-in condition. But, the single-family house is not large — 1,330 square feet, according to PropertyShark. And the ask is $799,000, a bump up for the area, no doubt.

Do you think it’s reasonable, given this house is renovated and most are not?

1163 New York Avenue [Halstead] GMAP

1163 new york avenue 1


What's Your Take? Leave a Comment

  1. Where did Brownstoner market place get the before pictures from? ; they are not a part of the current Brokers marketing?
    But that said, it is priced right for the property best use: it is in an R6 zone on a large lot. The way development is going a developer could buy this to build low income housing + community use space (Day Care etc) and do OK.
    Close to Downstate / Kings County as well as Brooklyn College, some new construction rentals with modern amenities will do well there.
    For all the frame house enthusiasts lets hope a home buyer steps forward quickly.
    The huge yard & the garages are a bigger draw than the number of bedrooms and bathrooms to many buyers and so rarely available in reasonable condition in this price range.

    • If that’s your target buyer, why put money into a gut renovation? It was purchased 1-2 years ago, totally decrepit. Why not sell it to a developer that way?

  2. It’s ambitious for East Flatbush, that’s for sure, especially a single-family without a ton of space (it’s only got 2 legit bedrooms plus a master suite type space in the attic).