case-shiller-1209.jpg
Case-Shiller came out with the December numbers for its 20-city index of real estate prices and the results weren’t particularly good: 15 out of 20 cities showed month-over-month declines, though the overall index managed to eke out a seasonally-adjusted increase of 0.3 percent. The good news is that the index staged a 5 percent comeback starting in April 2009 after a six-month run that saw it lose 11 percent. The bad news is the number of markets with positive monthly returns has gradually decreased over that time from 18 in June to 4 in December. It also doesn’t bode particularly well that the Federal Government is expected stop its purchases of mortgage-backed securities in March, which in turn is likely to lead to a rise in mortgage rates; meanwhile, market pressure from a rising number of foreclosures is expected to keep downward pressure on prices. Seeking Alpha all that means the country’s in for a double dip. Here in New York City, prices fell about 1 percent month-over-month and a little more than 6 percent year-over-year, not as bad as Las Vegas or Miami, but far worse than some other cities like Boston or San Francisco where the downturn started much earlier.
U.S. Home Prices Rise Modestly [NY Times]
Case-Shiller Adds to Confusion on Housing Market [WSJ]
Graphic from Seeking Alpha


What's Your Take? Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

  1. talk about an overstatement. saying CS has nothing to do with the NYC market is tantamount to saying the subprime crisis wouldn’t affect the broader real estate market. ha ha ha. of course it’s not measuring NYC market per se, but clearly metro area is linked to urban brownstones/ coops/ condos.

    otoh out of where did you pull the 200 number???

  2. In past bubbles and busts, the busts do not return to pre-bubble prices. Only to about 20 percent off peak. In the bubble times, prices double, triple, and quadruple.

  3. This is not the time to buy. Case Shiller (NY Met Area) may stay flat at 170, but that does not mean the price will be flat in NYC. Unlike the suburbs, NYC price is still above 200 (assuming that 2000 price = 100) and therefore has further to fall.

1 2 3 4 11