Original Bonita to Close
The original Bonita at 383 Bedford Avenue in Williamsburg is due to close on August 15, reports Brooklyn Based. The reasons are two-fold: 1) They’ve never been able to get a full liquor license, which is bummer for a place that should be doing a big business in Tequila; 2) The tenant-landlord relationship is irretrievably…

The original Bonita at 383 Bedford Avenue in Williamsburg is due to close on August 15, reports Brooklyn Based. The reasons are two-fold: 1) They’ve never been able to get a full liquor license, which is bummer for a place that should be doing a big business in Tequila; 2) The tenant-landlord relationship is irretrievably strained. (He hates me, co-owner Andrew Tarlow told BB. Always has.) Big bummer, but at least the restaurant’s younger sibling, Bonita II at 243 Dekalb Avenue in Fort Greene, is still going strong. GMAP
Photo by TapIt Water
Yes thats the one – what a shame.
Yes – proximity to a church (storefront church, next door) means you can only get a beer/wine license. Don’t remember the exact distance, that triggers it, but Bonita is well within it.
I haven’t been to Bonita in a couple of years, so I’ll take DH’s description of the slide in quality on faith. Too bad, as it was a great place.
Dittoburg – you’re talking about Matamoros Grocery, no? They lost their lease some time ago, I think. The cart that’s set up shop on Bedford between Metro and N 3rd may be the closest to what Matamoros was.
How can anyone hate Andrew?
Nice guy and always impeccably dressed.
I am kind of disappointed. I really like this place and go here often. Honestly surprised by the tone of the comments on this thread. all of the places owned by these guys are great. Luckily I can hit up La Superior for a mexican fix, which I thought was great the one time I went.
“waitress at bonita, bedford said (last night) that bonita, fg will become a marlow”
Well that would be cool!
maybe they weren’t willing to pay off the gov officials like they did in NJ
“Wonder why they never got approved for a liquor license.”
Proximity to a church, no?
food was great. service was spotty. rumor has it that sergio had to be shuffled between the 2 locations to watch over the zone-outting wait staff.
also fyi: waitress at bonita, bedford said (last night) that bonita, fg will become a marlow.
I used to go to the three sisters running the mexican food place in the back of the bodega on bedford between N6th and N7th. Are they still there?