Heights Trophy Property Up for Grabs
Last week 24 Remsen Street hit the market, offering a deep-pocketed buyer the chance to own a 9,250-square-foot, 12-bedroom property in prime Brooklyn Heights for $14,000,000. The building, which its listing broker Donald Brennan purchased in 2005 and renovated into four condos that hit the market in late 2008, is now being positioned as either…
Last week 24 Remsen Street hit the market, offering a deep-pocketed buyer the chance to own a 9,250-square-foot, 12-bedroom property in prime Brooklyn Heights for $14,000,000. The building, which its listing broker Donald Brennan purchased in 2005 and renovated into four condos that hit the market in late 2008, is now being positioned as either an investment opportunity or, potentially, a single-family mansion. Brennan has the following to say about the rationale behind the new listing: “When the work was complete in late 2008 market conditions were extremely poor but we advertised the units for sale anyway for a short period of time while we prepared to put the property into service as a rental property. I leased the 4 units in early 2009 and they are still occupied by tenants. As the real estate is extremely valuable due to its superior location, pre-existing non-conforming over-built bulk and attractive architectural style and details I am in no rush to dispose of it. A number of parties recently expressed interest in acquiring the property in its current configuration and use with the intention of using it as an owner-occupied rental property, so I put a price on it. The price equation includes a capitalized net operating income from three of the four rental units plus the market value of the remaining unit inclusive of the typical ownership premium. I thought I would advertise it more publicly while these parties are contemplating their next move.”
24 Remsen Street [Brennan Realty; 2nd Listing] GMAP
“as either an investment opportunity …” at a 38 GRM and a 2% cap rate? I don’t think so.
Maly’s price $8.5M seems closer to the ballpark for trophy investment property. That’s 23 x rent or a 3.7% cap rate.
“For godsakes, why would anybody choose to live in the West Village?”
The West Village is nice, and it’s convenient.
It is much more urbane and sophisticated than Brooklyn, which has improved a lot lately but is still more or less an overseas colony of Manhattan.
> So at that price point I’d take the West Village.
For godsakes, why would anybody choose to live in the West Village?
That’s right, not a penny over $8.5M!
$14M and the new owner would still need to do a top to bottom reno to convert back to a single family – so that’s going to jack the price up to what, nearly $20M?
No parking or elevator included in that price, either.
So at that price point I’d take the West Village.
I agree, ML.
Most NYC “mansions” have elevators. Not installing one was a miscalculation.
The Donald may need a wee lesson in the world of market assessment and analysis.
Donald, very interesting. I didn’t realize that you’d decided to rent, rather than sell, the units. I remember seeing photos and floor plans of the units and common areas, and they were really beautifully done.