NYT's Look at Blog Commenters
This weekend, the City section of the Sunday Times took a front-page look at the nature of the commenting culture on local blogs (in addition to a focus on Brownstoner, Curbed, Gowanus Lounge, GerritsenBeach.net, and Roosevelt Island 360 all got ink), something New York City has in greater numbers than other cities. While it didn’t…

This weekend, the City section of the Sunday Times took a front-page look at the nature of the commenting culture on local blogs (in addition to a focus on Brownstoner, Curbed, Gowanus Lounge, GerritsenBeach.net, and Roosevelt Island 360 all got ink), something New York City has in greater numbers than other cities. While it didn’t seem like a particularly new issue to us, hopefully it spread the gospel to the uninitiated. “For the past few years, blog comments sections, acting as virtual town squares, have offered residents around the country a forum in which to weigh in — and vent — on a wide spectrum of local issues,” went the article. “But given New York’s size and diversity, not to mention its fabled brashness, political energy and high emotion, its blogosphere is taking a particularly striking shape.” Yours truly was quoted about the no-brainer decision of allowing comments from the get-go of the blog, despite the fact that some of the established blogs at the time blocked comments. The piece wraps with a description of the Brownstoner End of the World party that took place last October and readers’ reaction online:
The next day, online, the partygoers spoke enthusiastically about the experience. Some noted that their virtual friends didn’t look like what they had expected. A poster named Slopefarm was shocked to discover that Montrose Morris was a woman. Ms. Morris got her own surprise, as she commented, tongue firmly in cheek: Slopefarm, good to meet you, too. I’m disappointed you didn’t have a stalk of organic, heritage, artisanal hay harvested by Bhutanese nuns between your teeth. You are in Park Slope, after all.
It’ll be interesting to see how much traffic the article generateswe’ll be able to report back in a few hours. Update: Traffic yesterday was about double the average for Sunday, but still not close to a normal weekday.
You Talkin’ to Me? [Brownstoner]
And it was ME DAMMIT, who received Quote of the Day!!!
DIBS, not sure. I’ll be cheering for the Eagles, though, wherever it is.
BRG, unlike others who rest on their laurels and are content with ongoing mediocre commenting after receiving a questionable QOTD honor on a particularly slow posting day
I don’t need validation. We’re all well aware of who thought up and organized the End of the World Party. (For those new to this blog, it was ME DAMMIT!!!)
Nice Article…Motroses’s prose need to be amplified for the masses!
Biff, you were inadvertently noted in the article, sort of. You were the organizer of the ‘End Party’
Does that make you feel better, now that DIBS admitted to thinking you’re a schmuck!
Where you going to watch the game next weekend Biff. You weren’t that bad.
Glad to see that I wasn’t the only one who assumed that MM was a dude.
This is wonderful! Montrose’s words of wisdom have spread to a larger audience thanks to slopefarm. And kudos to Brownstoner for the recognition.
“Then Biff arrived. :(”
DIBS, was it that bad hanging out with me??
I remember the first outing at Union Hall. I was the first one there and couldn’t figure out who might be whom coming in from brownstoner. Then MM, bxgrl and I all of a sudden just started chatting.
Then Biff arrived. 🙁
And for the record… I think the comments in Brownstoner is far more intelligent and meaningful than Curbed.
That place has turn in to a sh!t hole/
Agreed, Wasder.