BiggestSales101019.jpg
1. PARK SLOPE $3,662,500
858 Carroll Street GMAP
When this gorgeous 1-family Romanesque Revival house was House of the Day back in May, it has just hit the market with an asking price of $3,895,000. Five stories tall and more than 22 feet wide, it’s got lots of original charm and a good lookin’ kitchen. Average Reader Appraisal was $3,293,565. Entered into contract on 8/20/10; closed on 9/30/10; deed recorded on 10/13/10.

2. BROOKLYN HEIGHTS $1,563,013.75
360 Furman Street, Unit 1209 GMAP
StreetEasy doesn’t have a listing associated with this particular unit at One Brooklyn Bridge Park. Entered into contract on 8/5/10; closed on 10/4/10; deed recorded on 10/15/10.

3. PROSPECT HEIGHTS $1,550,000
107 St. Marks Avenue GMAP
According to its listing on StreetEasy, “This oversized 21′ wide brownstone… is currently a legal 4-family with one apt per floor… A grand parlor floor boasts soaring ceilings with wedding cake plaster detail, as well as a pier mirror, ornate marble mantel, arched raised-panel & etched glass pocket doors, window shutters, parquet flooring, etc.” Entered into contract on 7/19/10; closed on 10/4/10; deed recorded on 10/14/10.

4. COBBLE HILL $1,500,000
49 Douglass Street GMAP
“Endless possibilities exist in this 4-family, 25 foot wide brick townhouse… Original details exist throughout the house including decorative fireplaces with mantels on each floor, wide plank pine floors, pocket doors, oversized windows, and endless sunlight all day… the large backyard is perfect for gardener,” says its listing on StreetEasy. Asking price was $1,450,000. Entered into contract on 6/24/10; closed on 9/21/10; deed recorded on 10/14/10.

5. CARROLL GARDENS $1,400,000
43 4th Place GMAP
A House of the Day in August, this 3-story, 3-unit building seemed a bit lacking in charm and original details. Original asking price was $1,495,000, and unfortunately, the widget wasn’t running on its HOTD post. Entered into contract on 8/25/10; closed on 10/1/10; deed recorded on 10/13/10.

Photos from PropertyShark.


What's Your Take? Leave a Comment

  1. If it was consistently 10 to 15 percent off, then that tells you a lot about price.

    Why would agents talk down prices at other brokerages? That would only hurt their own sales. Unless you mean BHO is a real estate agent.

  2. I think the widget would have been totally fun if it was attached to each person’s username.

    As it was, it was obviously being abused by people and you know there are real estate agents crawling ALL OVER THIS BOARD trying to talk down other listings at competing brokerages.

    We’d see a 3 million dollar house with multiple widget bids at 1.7 million. THAT doesn’t bode well for this blog’s credibility more than no longer having the widget does!

  3. I was always ambivalent about the utility of the widget, but it was a fun game to play. Also fun to see how consistently off it was as a predictor of selling price. But it would be good to know whether it was removed for editorial or business reasons. But honestly, if you chart it over its history, what use did it serve? It was invariably 10-15% low, was clearly gamed by both bears and brokers, and was little more than a hot-or-not style metric that revealed nothing about the actual market. I sure wouldn’t want to subject my house to that, on the market or no.

    But if people miss it so much, just post your guesses in the comments. There’s more accountability that way, anyhow.