Condo of the Day: Montauk Club Duplex
It was only recently that we realized that part of the Montauk Club had been converted to condos several years. From what we can piece together, it looks like there are only six residential units, of which this 2,000-square-foot three-bedroom duplex is one. The interiors look pretty nice in a modern wayno evidence though of…

It was only recently that we realized that part of the Montauk Club had been converted to condos several years. From what we can piece together, it looks like there are only six residential units, of which this 2,000-square-foot three-bedroom duplex is one. The interiors look pretty nice in a modern wayno evidence though of any of the hardcore wood paneling that defines the lower floors. And clearly the location and views rock. So how does the $1,545,000 asking price strike you?
25 8th Avenue [Brown Harris Stevens] GMAP
Photo by gmpicket
I saw this apartment. It has very little period detail in fact none reallybut a lot of space. The renovations feels very 1990 and for that price you would expect something very updated–I would want to change the kitchen and bathrooms but could not afford it at that price. also there is a pretty high maintenance and then an on-going monthly assessment–given this i think it overpriced by about 300k. The space is nice but it is really a spacious 2 bedroom, the bedroom downstair is more of a den/ visitor space. there are two commercial business on the ground floor.
I saw this apartment. It has very little period detail in fact none reallybut a lot of space. The renovations feels very 1990 and for that price you would expect something very updated–I would want to change the kitchen and bathrooms but could not afford it at that price. also there is a pretty high maintenance and then an on-going monthly assessment–given this i think it overpriced by about 300k. The space is nice but it is really a spacious 2 bedroom, the bedroom downstair is more of a den/ visitor space. there are two commercial business on the ground floor.
Nice entertainment system! I mean, seriously, why would they put that photo in the mix? It says nothing about the apartment. What about a picture of the bathrooms? The bedrooms? Seems like a rather ordinary apartment.
Thank you 1:21. Comments like Matilda’s are absurd.
Matilda, I’m about to pick on you because I’ve heard that kind of response too many times on this board. Can you please fill us in on what is IN this year so we can rip out our kitchens and baths every 2 years? It’s not a pair of sneakers. It’s a kitchen!
When I saw your title, I was expecting over the top Victorian wooodwork, and some other period details, maybe some stained glass or parquet. Nada. Very disappointing. This is nice enough, but could be in any prewar building.
Not going to comment on prices, as I could buy an entire house and fix it up to perfection, in my nabe, for this, but that’s apples and oranges.
I’ve been in the period rooms downstairs, albeit 20 years ago, and they were fabulous. I hope all of that Victorian excess is still there.
This unit should be part of the Montauk Club again. The price is relatively low – but the landmark building is in desperate need of renovation, and that unit sits directly above what is an active bar.
I think this looks fantastic.
Low maint, great location.
A triplex.
I’ll take it.
uh oh…cherry cabinets, stainless steel appliances, black granite countertop. Very 2000.