And If You Believe That, I Have a Bridge to Sell You: The Men Who Sold the Brooklyn Bridge

The Brooklyn Bridge in the early 20th century. Photo via the Library of Congress


    You may or may not have heard the well-known phrase, “If you believe that, then I’ve got a bridge to sell you.” But are you familiar with the details of the conniving con men and the swindles that inspired it?

    The swindler is just as timeless a New York character as the swindled, so perhaps it will come as no surprise that many an unsuspecting fool has purchased the Brooklyn Bridge from a confidence man.

    Since the bridge’s completion in 1883, men and woman have made a living selling it to the gullible. There’s William McCloundy, or “I.O.U. O’Brien,” as he was known to police, who served two-and-a-half years in Sing Sing for posing as the Brooklyn Bridge’s owner and selling it to a tourist in 1901.

    McCloundy had a long history of false impersonations in the name of grand larceny, pretending to be a transatlantic liner captain and prison warden on different occasions, according to a 1928 New York Times article detailing one of McCloundy’s many arrests.

    Brooklyn Bridge History Prank Conmen Joey Skaggs

    Image via Harper’s Magazine

    Then there’s George C. Parker who, according to an article detailing his arrest (also in 1928), included selling the Brooklyn Bridge in his exploits as well. His record also shows that, while serving time, he once stole a sheriff’s hat and overcoat and simply walked out of the prison, the New York Times reported.

    The list goes on.

    As late as 1992, performance artist Joey Skaggs used a similar trick on the media, leaking a fake inter-office memo stating that the Dinkins administration, in an effort to raise funds for infrastructural repairs, was holding a lottery to rename the Brooklyn Bridge.

    Related Stories
    “The Bridge Is Falling”: The Story of the Brooklyn Bridge’s Deadly Stampede
    Happy Birthday, Brooklyn Bridge! Celebrating 133 Years of a New York Landmark [Photos]
    Latest Rendering for Planned Brooklyn Strand Proposes Elevator Access to Brooklyn Bridge

    Email with further comments, questions or tips. Follow Brownstoner on Twitter and Instagram, and like us on Facebook.

    Brooklyn in Your Inbox

    * indicates required

    What's Happening