subway tiles advice

OK i have a dilemma I buy the Gabriella casa vogue tiles at $5.95 a sf or do I get the rittenhouse dall tile at $3.00 a square foot. Now of money were raining down I’d get the gabriella its thicker handmade looking prettier. BUT money is getting to be an issue. Also I am going to be putting heavy shelves on the tile so drilling holes . Need help folks need opinions. Thanks