On a Roll at Brooklyn Fish Camp
Last night, we were talking a big game about trekking into the city to sample the famed lobster rolls at Pearl Oyster Bar for a celebratory birthday dinner… but after reading some reviews about the curt service there, we decided to hit up our old standby, Brooklyn Fish Camp, instead. We love the food there,…

Last night, we were talking a big game about trekking into the city to sample the famed lobster rolls at Pearl Oyster Bar for a celebratory birthday dinner… but after reading some reviews about the curt service there, we decided to hit up our old standby, Brooklyn Fish Camp, instead. We love the food there, and in our experience, their wait staff can’t be beat. Since they were out of their spicy conch soup, our server suggested their New England clam chowder instead. We asked if it was really good, and our she replied, “Yeah, it’s got bacon in it!” Obviously, we told her to bring it. We also got an order of fried oysters and clams (the former was heavenly, the latter a bit gristly), a couple of Sixpoint Brooklyn Brownstones, and a couple of lobster rolls. “Check it out,” our waitress said when she arrived with the rolls, served with mountains of thin-cut fries.
She placed them on the table, adding a quiet, “Yay!” You gotta love a wait staff that’s excited about the food they’re serving it was enough to convince us to try a couple of soul-satisfying desserts sweet banana pudding and chocolate chip pound cake with rich mascarpone ice cream. The only bummer? We should have celebrated on Tuesday when the daily special offers a cup of chowder, a lobster roll, and a beer for a mere $20.
Brooklyn Fishcamp [Homepage]
FYI, went to Fish Camp last night, hoping for the $20 special- they don’t have it anymore!
Food was good but I thought way over priced..why should I pay $30 for a lobster roll when in new england you can buy it at McDonalds for 2.50!!! I’ll wait!
i had the lobster potpie and spicy conch chowder…it was all amazing!
I went BFC once with a friend and it was pleasant enough. We paid with a credit card, signing off on a 59 dollar bill and when the card’s monthly statement showed up someone had added 100! Pretty shady.
Love BFC but I think they are WAY way way over priced…
From a born and bred Bostonian: Salt pork is a bit more traditional, but bacon is great in chowder, too.
To 1:50 PM – who feels so strongly about bacon. it is an ingredient in chowder recipes – I have been making it 35 years with bacon -its not something newfangled.
Please. I’m all for local Brooklyn rah rah, but BFC does not come close to Pearl. You gotta get out of the borough once in a while
My boyfriend and I go to Brooklyn Fish Camp almost every weekend. What a delight!