184-9th-street.jpg
184-9th-old.jpgWe spotted this building on West 9th Street, near Smith, the other day. Before its makeover, it was just a humble but proud Italianate townhouse like its brothers and sisters on the block. Now, well, we can spot several influences: some Spanish tile for the roof; a stucco-looking facade reminiscent of Greece; coral-colored Doric-ish columns, and those mini-balustrades. Looks from this DOB file that they added height and depth to the building back in 2007, and decided to make it stand out from its neighbors as well. Your reviews? GMAP
Photo from Property Shark.


What's Your Take? Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

  1. Ok most people hate it (and its not my taste either) BUT the real question is WHY do you hate it – do you hate it b/c it doesnt “fit in” with the neighbors; do you hate it b/c it is just ugly (anywhere); do you hate it b/c of the color, etc…..

    Personally I think it is fine – it isnt a historical area and while the design isnt all that great (anywhere) having every building be the “same” is kinda boring – but it might just “not fit in” a bit too much – especially for an otherwise mediocre design

  2. If they had left off the balconies and balustrades, it wouldn’t be all that offensive. I can live with the color and even the Spanish tile, some commenters are right, a bit of variety makes an interesting streetscape, especially since the building on the left has already been modernized and mucked up with that ground floor bay window.

    But the balconies totally kill it. What were they thinking?

1 8 9 10 11 12 13