Two things: first, a brownish particulate accumulates in the screen of the showerhead. I have to clean it every couple of weeks; second, last night, we ran out of hot water, and the cold water that came out at the end left a reddish residue on the floor of the shower. Is this as ominous as it sounds? What does a new one cost (large enough for a family of 3 in the upper duplex of a 4 story brownstone)? Thanks for any insight


What's Your Take? Leave a Comment

  1. before going to H/D – go to ebay and by 10% or 20% off coupon. it costs $3 on ebay but would save you a $100.

  2. Similar thing happened to me back in December, so I replaced it. If your heater is more than 10 years old, you should look into it and fix it before it starts to leak. You probably have a while, but I’d use the time to get the money together (mine cost $1200 installed).

  3. If you need a new tank, just go to Home Depot or Lowe’s. Buy one with installation. the price will vary as to how long the warranty is. I think they are 2 yrs, 4 yrs and 8.

  4. You might try hooking a hose to the tap near the bottom of the tank and running it into drain or better yet a toilet to see if it will run clear after a while. you might have some accumulated sludge in the bottom. If it’s a gas heater take a flashlight and look under the tank where the pilot is and see if you can see or hear a drip. If it’s electric, well, look on the floor.