My landlords just increased my rent from $1600-$1850, making that a 15.6% increase. I’m a month-to-month renter, so i know they have the right to raise it to whatever they want. However, that is way above standard, can I negotiate?


Comments

  1. When my tenants lease was about to expire he wanted to know if I would drop the rent by $400. a month. He is an investment banker and said his bonus will be very little this year.
    Meanwhile all the banks went south.

    I should have put 2 and 2 together and got my money out of the stock market but I didn’t.
    It never occurred to me to go deeper into the conversation.
    Obviously he knew something and I didn’t read between the lines.

    The apartment is vacant. Do I care? No.

    For me it is an opportunity to renovate my apartment and use the extra one till the work is done,
    It is all in the same building.

  2. I think you should look and compare for the price you are paying. I like the comment from rh. I’m a landlord too and I value good tenants: both commercial and residental and I raise rents based on how much my taxes, insurance and utilites go up rather than on market rates. I like to keep good tenants. So there is a lot of advice out there but if you have an alternative place that you can move to, then your bargaining hand is stronger — but not a guarantee. Don’t try to bluff because if they call you, either you are forced to move out from embarrassment or you look like a liar.

  3. bktycoon – yes, a small 1 bedroom in a narrow brownstone. it’s about a 14″ wide building. it’s definitely no larger than 500 sq ft.

    if we do stay and pay the increase, am i entitled to a new paint job (or is that only for stabilized/controlled apts? we’ve been here 3.5 years and have not asked for any fixes in the apt. and it could definitely use some. my fault for not signing a lease, as they would non have been able to raise the rent until march of next year.

  4. The landlord is running a business. His business expenses (mortgage, utilities, etc) have most likely gone up, so his fee for services (providing a house) have gone up.

    Don’t take it personally. He can easily find a replacement that can pay that amount, and be on time each month, and probably walk his dog too. You don’t hold any bargaining chips.

  5. Elizabeth –

    This is a troubling situation, especially considering the part about walking their dog and watching their kid. Landlords can really be jerks. May i ask for more details re: sq. footage? Im assuming this is a 1BR. If this apt is over 500 sq ft, 1850 isnt that far out of line in cobble hill. i know, it sucks, but cobble hill isnt a cheap area unfortunately…

  6. If you choose to stay and pay the increase, forget the dog walking and babysitting for free. As a landlord and pet owner (no kids) I know how valuable that is! A dog walk runs about $20-25 and God knows how much babysitting is. Not to mention, finding someone you like.

  7. Insurance rates & water rates have also gone up. Some analysts think that, with fewer people able to buy, rentals will be more desireable & therefore rents will increase.