The Top Ten Hardware Stores in Brooklyn
The results are in from our thoroughly unscientific poll to determine the most popular mom-and-pop hardware stores in Brooklyn. (To be fair, given the reader demographic, it would be fairer to say “in Brownstone and North Brooklyn.”) So without further ado, click through to see the list in the order of popularity based on a…

The results are in from our thoroughly unscientific poll to determine the most popular mom-and-pop hardware stores in Brooklyn. (To be fair, given the reader demographic, it would be fairer to say “in Brownstone and North Brooklyn.”) So without further ado, click through to see the list in the order of popularity based on a total of 654 responses.
1. Mazzone’s True Value, 470 Court Street
2. Tony’s Hardware, 181 Smith Street
3. Leopoldi’s True Value, 415 5th Avenue
4. Pintchik, 478 Bergen Street
5. Tarzian Hardware, 194 7th Avenue
6. Sister’s Community Hardware, 900 Fulton Street
7. Crest True Value, 558 Metropolitan Avenue
8. Almac Hardware, 2 Newkirk Plaza
9. R&A Hardware, 109 5th Avenue
10. (tied) Greschler’s, 660 5th Avenue
Big Brothers Hardware, 1327 Fulton
“thoroughly unscientific” is right – that would explain why a place like Pintchik is #4 and Almac, our go-to place for everything having to do with our house, is below at #8! Almac rocks…
All I know is, I really, really miss Sid’s.
randolph – Brownstoner cares! Man’s gotta eat and can’t sell ads to the two orange and blue corporate big box stores.
Ok now do a survey which hardware store (of any size) is the best…..sorry but Lowes crushes all of them.
Home Depot is a $hithole – so on that one we agree
I dont need that much help – I need choices and organization. I want to go in, find what I need and leave. I havent been to everyone of the places listed (but used to go to Mazzone alot) and it was always a situation where I couldnt find what I wanted, then they’d help me and they’d have something ‘close.’
So my criteria is inventory; well laid out.