Checking In On Fulton Mall Arby's
Earlier this week Lost City stopped by the Arby’s at 372 Fulton Street on the Fulton Mall in Downtown Brooklyn. Since finally gaining approval from LPC in June for the interior renovation, the franchisee has been working steadily on the space. Lost City was able to stick its head inside and learned that the fast…

Earlier this week Lost City stopped by the Arby’s at 372 Fulton Street on the Fulton Mall in Downtown Brooklyn. Since finally gaining approval from LPC in June for the interior renovation, the franchisee has been working steadily on the space. Lost City was able to stick its head inside and learned that the fast food joint will be ready to open “in a few weeks.” Curious, we decided to head over there yesterday afternoon and were able get take this photo from the doorway. You can’t really see the build-out at the rear which is where most of the renovation action is happening but there’s certainly plenty of activity going on.
Gage & Arby’s Will Be Ready in a Few Weeks [Lost City]
LPC Gives Arby’s Go-Ahead for Historic Fulton Mall Space [Brownstoner]
Fulton Mall Arby’s Revealed [Brownstoner]
LPC Sends Arby’s Back to the Prep Station [Brownstoner]
Arby’s Planning to Take Gage & Tollner Space [Brownstoner]
Rumor: Fast Food for Gage & Tollner Space [Brownstoner]
I can hardly bear to watch this. Hope to hell they don’t f*** up that amazing interior. And, yeh Brenda, Edna Lewis was a goddess and one of the finest chefs to ever cook in this town. When she was well into her 70s, she was invited to make the dessert for a banquet in Atlanta. She took the train from NYC with her pie crusts packed in ice in large tea crates. What a dame.
I’d bet my right arm that not one of you ever ate here when it was Gage and Tollner.
Roy is far far better. but that arby sauce was good.
I wish they could have moved the whole interior to a different location so it could be really enjoyed and respected. But that’s not what landmark is about. ( sigh )
> better Arby’s than empty…
I guess, though I find myself wondering if “death with dignity” would be a better fate than this.
I think it’s just sort of amusing… fast food joint takes over a fancy landmarked property. Silly indeed. I don’t like Arby’s very much — but when I was a kid, I could not get enough Arby’s Sauce! I got my mom to buy the bottles of it and I would mix it with ketchup so it would last! Mmmm.
I eat plenty of fast food but arby’s is horrible.
And a nail salon upstairs where the family that used to own run the place lived (pre-Edna Lewis days)
I’d prefer a Roy Rogers
Two regulars, an order of potato cakes, and a root beer, please. Here’s a twenty.