I have a three family brownstone in Brooklyn. Two 40 gallon water heaters in the basement plumbed together. On one heater the pilot won’t stay lit, so I called GE(American Hot Water Heater) about getting it fixed under warranty.It’s taken a week and a half and a number of calls to finally get someone out, who’s coming today, but when I was trying to get them here and explaining that I have tenants I have to provide hot water to for emphasis, The GE rep came back and said because the water heater is in a multi family, the warranty is void. Anyone else ever run into this? Any ideas about what to do about it? NY state dept of consumer affairs. All brownstones as I understand it were originally built as single family dwellings.


Comments

  1. SteamMan, being as my GE fridge was just past the warranty time, and we spent a boatload of cabbage on it, I feel justified. I forgot to mention in my first post that it was the second time we had a problem. And thanks for the compliment!

    Starfish, there are many commercial units that would apply nicely in a 3 family building.
    The reason the water heater manufacturers do this is that every one would install a residential unit in a commercial app for way less money and then try to warranty every unit they have. Residential units are built for single family homes with a six year (or ten) warranty because it’s only being used by a few people in one family. Residential units are not built for use by 3 or 4 families which would mean use by upwards to 20 people + a day.
    Commercial units all have a 3 year warranty. If maintained properly a water heater will usually oulast the warranty period.
    I’ve sold many(and I mean many) commercial water heaters for buildings with just a few units to buildings with 100’s of units.
    A nice little Laars PW0175 mighty therm “commercial” water heater and a 119 gallon storage tank would be great for a 3 family dwelling.

  2. In all fairness, a tank only runs you $500. A service call costs GE $100 so you shouldn’t expect them to be too generous with them. The warranty on a water tank is really to guarantee that the bottom won’t rust through for X number of years. Like Bill said, the thermocouple is considered expendable. You can easily replace it yourself.

  3. Seems like a ridiculous rule.
    A “commercial” water heater is huge. Way too much for a 3-unit building, or even ten units.
    It’s a way of presenting what sounds like a ten year warranty but is really a one-year. They fool a lot of people.

  4. To elaborate on SteamMan’s post. When a residential water heater is installed in a dwelling with more than one family it’s considered to be a ‘commercial’ application, voiding the warranty.
    All water heater manufacturers(not just GE) have this policy.
    I have a GE fridge. When we had an issue with a bad board the GE service tech put it in as a warranty and we only paid for his service call. The fridge was already out of warranty for 3 months. He saved us about $400.00 and he was sent by GE.