Have you checked Old Good Things? The showroom is on W24th Street in the city. They also have an enormous amount of salvage in their warehouse in PA that’s pretty well cataloged, and they may be able to match any pieces or trim that you need. Hope this helps, good luck!
Modern Way Lumber on 4th at St. Marks (open M-F only).
http://www.abbingdon.com/
On Utica avenue here in Brooklyn. You should be able to match the pattern online–they might deliver depending on the amount you need.
standard tinsmith
http://www.tinsmith.com
Have you checked Old Good Things? The showroom is on W24th Street in the city. They also have an enormous amount of salvage in their warehouse in PA that’s pretty well cataloged, and they may be able to match any pieces or trim that you need. Hope this helps, good luck!