City Lawyers Push for Gowanus Rezoning Lawsuit to Be Dropped After Mayor’s Executive Order

Sketch of a possible view from 3rd Street. Image via NYC Department of City Planning


A state court judge must toss the ongoing lawsuit holding up the Gowanus neighborhood rezoning following a mayoral executive order permitting virtual public land use hearings, lawyers for the city argued Wednesday.

Mayor Bill de Blasio signed a directive on March 13 explicitly allowing hearings for the city’s Uniform Land Use Review Procedure (ULURP) to be held remotely, aiming to clear up a months-long legal battle about whether officials needed to hold the gatherings in person amid the pandemic.

“Virtual meetings held during the pandemic make sense, have increased participation among the public in the land use process, and are 100 percent justified under the mayor’s executive order,” said a spokesman for the city’s Law Department, Nick Paolucci, in a statement Wednesday.

Groups opposing the large-scale land use change that could bring some 8,200 new housing units to the low-slung nabe along the toxic canal previously argued that the city’s plans to hold ULURP hearings via Zoom was against the City Charter, which requires such meetings to be held at a “convenient place of public assembly,” in the district or somewhere centrally-located in the borough.

The opponents, Voice of Gowanus and Friends and Residents of Greater Gowanus, sued the city on January 15 and the court granted a temporary restraining order that day, blocking the scheduled January 19 start date of the rezoning.

gowanus brooklyn

Photo by Susan De Vries

Critics of the lawsuit said the legal move was a cynical ploy to stall the project for long enough so the roughly seven month public review process wouldn’t conclude before the end of 2021, when a new mayor takes office and elections shake up the City Council, which has veto power in the process.

Five of the six candidates looking to succeed incumbent local Councilmember Brad Lander have said they would oppose the current rezoning plan, Bklyner reported.

At the last virtual court hearing on February 4, Brooklyn Supreme Court Judge Katherine Levine said she needed more time to further determine whether the Department of City Planning — the agency proposing the rezoning — was doing enough to meet the “public assembly” requirements.

Governor Cuomo previously issued an executive order allowing public hearings to go remote across the Empire State, but a lawyer for the rezoning’s opponents, Jason Zakai, argued that the gubernatorial edict didn’t go far enough to specify ULURP, which has the additional provision of “public assembly” other gatherings don’t require.

City lawyer Christopher King countered that Zakai was too narrowly interpreting the law, saying the charter doesn’t spell out meetings have to be in-person.

Zakai did not immediately provide further comment.

gowanus green site

Photo by Susan De Vries

De Blasio’s Saturday directive states that hearings and meetings related to ULURP may be held without meeting in person, “to avoid continued disputes regarding whether such hearings and meetings may be held remotely,” the order reads.

A second aspect of the opponents’ lawsuit claimed that the agency failed to give locals proper notice about the land-use change’s start. However, Judge Levine indicated at last month’s hearing that she believed the city did fulfill that requirement.

The city’s legal team called on Justice Levine in March 17 court filings to dismiss the case following this order, adding that the legal battle is stalling the chance for the project’s benefits to come to Gowanus.

“We’re urging the court to dismiss this case because there is no legal basis to support these claims,” Paolucci said. “This litigation is preventing community voices from being heard and is delaying the creation of jobs, housing, open spaces, and a number of other community amenities.”

Editor’s note: A version of this story originally ran in Brooklyn Paper. Click here to see the original story.

Related Stories

Sign up for amNY’s COVID-19 newsletter to stay up to date on the latest coronavirus news throughout New York City. Email with further comments, questions or tips. Follow Brownstoner on Twitter and Instagram, and like us on Facebook.

Brooklyn in Your Inbox

* indicates required

What's Happening