Top 10

Overall
Best Food
Best Service
Best Ambience

Pizza

Name Neighborhood Cuisine Median Entree Rating
Roberta's Roberta's
261 Moore Street
(718) 417-1118
Bushwick Pizza, Italian, Brunch Spot $12.50 4.31
Lucali Lucali
575 Henry Street
(718) 858-4086
Carroll Gardens Pizza, Italian $9 (for half a pizza) 4.25
Restaurant of the Day: Motorino Restaurant of the Day: Motorino
319 Graham Avenue
(718) 599-8899
Williamsburg Pizza, Italian, Brunch Spot $14 per pizza 4.25
Caserta Vecchia Caserta Vecchia
221 Smith Street
(718) 624-7549
Boerum Hill Italian, Pizza $13.50 3.85
Amorina Amorina
624 Vanderbilt Avenue
(718) 230-3030
Prospect Heights Pizza, Italian $12.50 3.81
House of Pizza & Calzone House of Pizza & Calzone
132 Union Street
(718) 624-9107
Columbia Street Waterfront Pizza, Italian $14 for 18" pizza 3.81
Bar Toto Bar Toto
411 11th Street
(718) 768-4698
Park Slope Italian, Pizza $10.50 3.72
Layla Jones Layla Jones
214 Court Street
(718) 624-2361
Cobble Hill Pizza, Italian $10 3.43
Anthony's Anthony's
426A Seventh Avenue
(718) 369-8315
South Slope Italian, Pizza $13 3.43
Graziella's Graziella's
232 Vanderbilt Avenue
(718) 789-5663
Clinton Hill Pizza, Italian $12 3.35
Williamsburgh Cafe Williamsburgh Cafe
170 Wythe Avenue
(718) 387-5855
Williamsburg American, Pizza, Brunch Spot $16 3.27
Sam's Sam's
238 Court Street
(718) 596-3458
Cobble Hill Pizza, Italian $15 3.25
Francesco's Francesco's
531 Henry Street
(718) 834-0863
Carroll Gardens Italian, Pizza $11.50 3.25
215 Cucina Napoletana 215 Cucina Napoletana
215 Columbia Street
(718) 858-2960
Columbia Street Waterfront Italian, Pizza $10.50 3.2
Two Boots Brooklyn Two Boots Brooklyn
514 2nd Street
(718) 499-3253
Park Slope Pizza, Cajun/Creole, Brunch Spot $12.95 3.14
Acqua Santa Acqua Santa
556 Driggs Avenue
(718) 384-9695
Williamsburg Italian, Pizza, Brunch Spot $14 3.12
Giardini Pizza Giardini Pizza
363 Smith Street
(718) 596-5320
Carroll Gardens Pizza, Italian $15 for plain round pie 3.06
Toby's Public House Toby's Public House
686 Sixth Avenue
(718) 788-1186
Greenwood Heights Pizza, Italian $14 per pizza 3.04
Franny's Franny's
295 Flatbush Avenue
(718) 230 0221
Prospect Heights Italian, Pizza $16 2.93
Savoia Savoia
277 Smith Street
(718) 797-2727
Carroll Gardens Italian, Pizza, Brunch Spot $12.95 2.88
Mama Maria's Mama Maria's
307 Court Street
(718) 246-2601
Carroll Gardens Italian, Pizza $15 2.84
DiFara DiFara
1424 Avenue J
(718) 258-1367
Midwood Pizza, Italian $4-$5 per slice 2.79
Grimaldi's Grimaldi's
19 Old Fulton Street
(718) 858-4300
Dumbo Pizza $7 (half a large pizza) 2.6
Ignazio's Ignazio's
4 Water Street
(718) 522-2100
Dumbo Pizza, Italian $19 per medium pizza 2.25
Tutta Pasta Tutta Pasta
160 7th Avenue
(718) 788-9500
Park Slope Italian, Pizza $15.95 2.22
Sal's Pizzeria Sal's Pizzeria
305 Court Street
(718) 852-6890
Carroll Gardens Pizza, Italian $15 for a large pie 1.96
South Brooklyn Pizza South Brooklyn Pizza
451 Court Street
(718) 852-6018
Carroll Gardens Pizza $12 per pizza 1.95