HDC Pushes Against Coignet Stone Lot Reduction



The Landmarks Preservation Commission may have voted to approve a request to reduce the lot around the Coignet Stone building on the Whole Foods site in Gowanus, but a prominent preservation organization is protesting the decision. The Historic Districts Council had the following to say about the matter in an email blast that went out yesterday: “This proposal is an effort [for Whole Foods] to avoid the normal Landmarks Preservation Commission review process. The owners of the Coignet Building should be required to present plans at a public hearing to show how their proposal relates to the designated property. Otherwise, this will point the way for all who want to build upon a landmarked site and avoid LPC oversight.” The proposal still has to be approved by the City Planning Commission and then the City Council Subcommittee on Landmarks, which should happen within the next couple months. Meanwhile, HDC started a petition asking for “proper protection” for the Coignet Stone building and a public hearing about the request to reduce the lot size.
LPC Approves Reduction of Coignet Stone Lot [Brownstoner]
Preservationists: Don’t Shrink Gowanus Landmark’s Lot [Brownstoner]
LPC Hearing on Reduction of Gowanus Building’s Lot [Brownstoner] GMAP

By Emily | | Comment

LPC Approves Reduction of Coignet Stone Lot



Yesterday the Landmarks Preservation Commission voted unanimously to reduce the size of the landmark Coignet Stone Company Building’s lot on 3rd Avenue and 3rd Street. The proposal was to reduce the lot from approximately 125 feet to 55 feet on the 3rd Avenue side, and from 55 feet to 40 feet on the 3rd Street side to allow more room for the construction of the planned Whole Foods. At the public hearing last month, preservationists spoke out against shrinking the lot, with the Historic Districts Council saying, “It is troublesome that after years of planning by Whole Foods, the company is now only dealing with the fact that it owns a designated site and is asking the landmark to bear the brunt of the project.” Whole Foods does not own the building but promised to restore it and began some renovation work last year. It sounds as though the BSA was waiting for this LPC decision to come through before voting on Whole Foods’ variance request, so this clears the way for that to happen next month.
Preservationists: Don’t Shrink Gowanus Landmark’s Lot [Brownstoner]
LPC Hearing on Reduction of Gowanus Building’s Lot [Brownstoner] GMAP

By Emily | | Comment

Preservationists: Heights Cinema Shouldn’t be Demolished



There was news recently about how Tom Caruana, the owner of the building that houses the Brooklyn Heights Cinema, at 70 Henry Street, intends to demolish the structure in order to build a new condo, but it turns out Caruana is thinking twice about his plans following criticism from neighborhood preservationists. The Eagle reports on how Caruana decided not to present his plans to Community Board 2′s Land Use Committee:

Both Robert Perris, district manager of Community Board 2, and Judy Stanton, executive director of the Brooklyn Heights Association, told the Eagle that this decision followed a meeting between the building owner and the Heights Association’s own Landmarks Committee. She said that the committee, which contains three architectural historians, did research on the building’s history and came to the conclusion that it was an integral part of the Brooklyn Heights Landmark District and should not be demolished. The circa-1895 building was always a commercial building, but had a varied history, before it was converted into a cinema around 1970. Stanton said that research has revealed that the building, as originally constructed, was made of fine brick, had cast-iron columns and other details that were consistent with the neighborhood. Even though many of these details were later covered up or painted over, she says, “four-fifths of the original masonry still exists.” After the presentation, the owner apparently decided he had more homework to do.

Heights Cinema Plans on Hold [Eagle]
Photo via PropertyShark

By Gabby | | Comment

LPC Designates Bank, OKs 30 Henry Street Design



Besides holding a public hearing for the expansion of the Crown Heights landmark district yesterday, the LPC also voted to landmark the Williamsburg branch of the Public National Bank of New York at 47-49 Graham Avenue, between Moore and Varet streets, and approved a new design for the condo planned at 30 Henry Street in Brooklyn Heights. Here’s the writeup on the Public National Bank from its designation report: “The bank, considered one of [architect] Eugene Schoen’s most interesting and intact architectural commissions, was designed in the neo-Classical style and completed in 1923. Designed in the form of a one-story temple, the building is a rare example in New York City of early 20th century Viennese influence… The building, clad in cast-stone, features rusticated columns and corner piers on both of its main facades that framed rectangular and round arched windows, with panels and entrance surrounds featuring a combination of classical and Secessionist ornament.” LPC Spokesperson Elisabeth de Bourbon also reported that a design was approved for 30 Henry Street. The commission voted against a prior iteration of the design last week. We haven’t seen the new renderings yet.
Photo via PropertyShark

By Emily | | Comment

Lots of Support for More Crown Heights Landmarking



Yesterday 17 people testified at the Landmarks Preservation Commission’s public hearing to expand the Crown Heights North Historic District. Sixteen of them spoke in favor of landmarking, with one person who testified saying he was neither opposed nor in favor and had more questions. LPC made no vote. Our own Montrose Morris attended the hearing and reports back: “There were many more people from the community there… they were predominantly senior citizens who had lived in the neighborhood for years, and were proud to be there. It was really a moving and touching moment. I saw people I know to be long time homeowners, a minister, an auxiliary policeman, and community and police precinct board members. There were also a lot of just folks, both older and younger. I was very proud of us.” She also said the Commission pointed out the significance of the former Shaare Zedek Synagogue, now Historic First Church of God in Christ, at 221 Kingston Avenue, at Park Place. She says, “LPC called it one of the finest synagogue buildings in the city, and very much worthy of landmark protection.” You can see a picture of the synagogue after the jump.
LPC Considering Crown Heights North Phase III Today [Brownstoner]
Photo via LPC
(more…)

By Emily | | Comment

LPC Considering Crown Heights North Phase III Today



The Landmarks Preservation Commission is holding a public hearing today on the proposed designation of the Crown Heights North III Historic District, which consists of approximately 640 homes between Albany and Brooklyn avenues. The first phase of the district was made up of 472 homes, followed by last year’s landmarking of an area with 610 more houses in the second phase. According to the LPC Designation Report [pdf], “The proposed Crown Heights North III Historic District contains a rich variety of late-19th- and early-20th-century residential buildings, including long blocks of well-preserved row houses, the inviting enclaves of Revere, Virginia, and Hampton places, and an extraordinary collection of ‘Kinko’ houses—perhaps the most extensive and varied group of these remarkable two-family houses in the entire city. It also includes one of the neighborhood’s great houses of worship, the former Shaari Zedek Synagogue (Simeon D. Eisendrath and B. Horitz, 1922-25) at the southeast corner of Kingston Avenue and Park Place.” You can see some photographs of noteable buildings in the district here. Check back for a report on today’s hearing.

By Emily | | Comment

LPC: 30 Henry Design Could be Better



The Eagle files an extensive report about yesterday’s Landmarks Preservation Commission hearing about the plans for the new building at 30 Henry Street in Brooklyn Heights. The commissioners ultimately asked the developer and BKSK Architects to tweak the design, saying details such as the entryway could be improved upon, with LPC Chair Robert Tierney noting that “I find it appropriate now and I would openly embrace it, but I agree with my colleagues that it could be a better building.” Some preservationists spoke in favor of the current design, calling it contextual and appropriate, but reps from the Brooklyn Heights Association called it “boring” and argued for a more contemporary look. Architect Jonathan Marvel, for example, had the following to say: “It’s a threshold site to this district. It’s not an infill building, but a gateway building. …We implore you to inspire, to delight, to raise the bar on originality.”
Design of New Heights Building: Mishmash of Contextualism or Appropriate? [Eagle]
30 Henry Application Returns to Landmarks Tomorrow [Brownstoner]
No Decision From LPC on 30 Henry Build [Brownstoner]
Renderings Revealed for 30 Henry Street [Brownstoner]
30 Henry Street Chasing a Waterfall [Brownstoner]
Brooklyn Eagle Building on the Market [Brownstoner] GMAP

By Gabby | | Comment

30 Henry Application Returns to Landmarks Tomorrow



The application for a new five-story, six-unit Brooklyn Heights condo at 30 Henry Street hits the Landmarks Preservation Commission for a second time tomorrow. At the previous LPC meeting about the proposal, the commission didn’t take action on the plans because there wasn’t a quorum. All the renderings can be found here. If you’re interested in speaking at the public hearing, it begins at approximately 10:45 a.m. Think this design will make it through this time around?
No Decision From LPC on 30 Henry Build [Brownstoner]
Renderings Revealed for 30 Henry Street [Brownstoner]
30 Henry Street Chasing a Waterfall [Brownstoner]
Brooklyn Eagle Building on the Market [Brownstoner] GMAP

By Emily | | Comment

No Decision From LPC on 30 Henry Build


This Tuesday the LPC considered a developer’s plans to demolish the Brooklyn Eagle building at 30 Henry Street and construct a five-story, six-unit condo building. The result was anticlimactic: an LPC rep says no action was taken because there was no quorum. Guess we’ll find out the fate of this design in the new year.
Renderings Revealed for 30 Henry Street [Brownstoner]
30 Henry Street Chasing a Waterfall [Brownstoner]
Brooklyn Eagle Building on the Market [Brownstoner] GMAP

By Emily | | Comment

Preservationists: Don’t Shrink Gowanus Landmark’s Lot



Yesterday the Landmarks Preservation Commission held a hearing regarding the application to reduce the lot size of the landmark Coignet Stone Company Building on 3rd Street and 3rd Avenue. The proposal is to reduce the size of the lot from approximately 125 feet to 55 feet on the 3rd Avenue side, and from 55 feet to 40 feet on the 3rd Street side, a measure that would allow more room for the construction of the planned Whole Foods. Seven people testified about the proposal, and all of them opposed the reduction of the lot. Friends and Residents of Greater Gowanus (FROGG), the Pratt Institute for Gowanus Studio, and the HDC also submitted written opposition. HDC’s testimony was representative: “It is troublesome that after years of planning by Whole Foods, the company is now only dealing with the fact that it owns a designated site and is asking the landmark to bear the brunt of the project. As shown in renderings, plans and elevations… the Coignet Building would be engulfed by new structures, while the other half of the block would be a parking lot.” Meanwhile, Marty Markowitz submitted the only testimony that wasn’t completely opposed to the plans: “From the outset, I found it acceptable for the Whole Foods Market to abut the Coignet Building. However, should LPC find it appropriate to retain some of the existing yards as nominal side yards to serve as a buffer between the two properties, I certainly would not have a concern with designating such space… so long as this would not compromise construction of the Whole Foods site.” The LPC did not take a final vote on the proposal. It hasn’t been a great few weeks for Whole Foods: There was no resolution in the BSA hearing last week concerning the grocer’s application to build a bigger store than zoning allows.
LPC Hearing on Reduction of Gowanus Building’s Lot [Brownstoner] GMAP

By Emily | | Comment

Spotlight On: St. Marks Between New York and Kingston



The homes across from the Brooklyn Children’s Museum in Crown Heights are a spectacular mix of styles, starting with the villa-like corner mansion at #839. Known as the Dean Sage House, we’ve covered it here before. Montrose Morris is represented at #855-877, the Romanesque Revival twin-mansion. The rest is a mix of Queen Anne, Renaissance Revival, and Beaux Arts style, all ornate and impressive. Read all about the history of St. Marks Avenue in this Walkabout installment. And, of course, the Children’s Museum is across the street, looking something like a yellow submarine. The building took the place of two old Victorian mansions when it was built in 1976-77. This entire block was part of Phase 1 of Crown Heights landmarking.

By Emily | | Comment

LPC Hearing on Reduction of Gowanus Building’s Lot


Next Tuesday the Landmarks Preservation Commission will hold a public hearing on an application to reduce the lot size of the landmark Coignet Stone Company Building on 3rd Street and 3rd Avenue. The reduced lot size will help make way for the construction of the long-planned Whole Foods. (Separately, the BSA is considering the request for a variance for the Whole Foods build today.) The proposal is to reduce the size of the lot from approximately 125 feet to 55 feet on the 3rd Avenue side, and from 55 feet to 40 feet on the 3rd Street side. Some upkeep of the building, which has sat unused for years and is in shabby shape, began earlier this year. Whole Foods, which doesn’t own the property, has pledged to renovate it as part of its construction plans. GMAP

By Emily | | Comment

Closing Bell: Petition to Landmark More of Fort Greene


The Fort Greene Association set up a petition for the NYC Landmarks Committee to extend landmarking in Fort Greene. Boundaries, proposed this September, extend the district onto Myrtle from Carlton to Vanderbilt, around Deklab and Ashland, and below Fulton Street over to Adelphi. As the petition says, “We know that from its beginning in 1978, Historic Designation has benefited our area. Virtually all derelict housing and empty lots have been revived, bringing with it new pride and stability for a thriving multi-ethnic community. Additionally in fulfillment of the neighborhood promise many new business have arrived to flourish here because Historic Designation stimulated a resourceful core of consumers. For these and many other reasons, we again request a calendared hearing soonest by the LPC for an extended Fort Greene Historic District.” To sign the petition, go here.

By Emily | | Comment

Roof Support for Carlton Mews Church


Back in October, repair work began on the Carlton Mews Church at 233 Adelphi Street, the building previously in danger of collapse. Of particular concern was the building’s roof, which was deteriorating and allowing water to pour through. Now the roof has received some much-needed support. The plan is to remove the slate, followed by a full building reinforcement.
Work Begins At the Carlton Mews Church [Brownstoner]
Carlton Mews Church to be Saved From Danger of Collapse [Brownstoner] GMAP DOB

By Emily | | Comment

Will a Visitors’ Center Lure Tourists to Green-Wood?



We missed the Brooklyn Daily story yesterday about Green-Wood Cemetery’s pending purchase of of the landmark McGovern-Weir Florist building that talked about how the cemetery’s motivation for buying and renovating the structure has to do with making Green-Wood more attractive to tourists: “Even with its history, the 173-year-old cemetery just south of Prospect Park hasn’t been a huge tourist draw since the horse-and-buggy days — though in recent years, the cemetery has reached out to a new audience with tours and site-specific dance pieces.” The cemetery intends to turn the building into a visitors’ center and museum. Meanwhile, Aaron Brashear of the Concerned Citizens of Greenwood Heights is quoted as saying that he thinks renovating the long-dilapidated structure on 25th Street and 5th Avenue will be “a win for both the neighborhood and the cemetery.” The sale of the building hasn’t made it to public records yet, but it was listed for $1,500,000 along with an adjacent wood-frame house. We wonder how much a thorough renovation is going to cost.
Green-Wood’s New Gateway? [Brooklyn Daily]
City Council Approves Sale of Landmark Florist Building [Brownstoner]
Landmark Greenwood Florist Building in Contract [Brownstoner]
Landmarked Florist Building Up For Sale [Brownstoner] GMAP

By Gabby | | Comment

LPC Approves Final Design for 121-23 Fort Greene Place



Yesterday the LPC approved final plans to renovate the double townhouse at 121-23 Fort Greene Place. The building is going to see an extensive interior and exterior overhaul. Alex Barrett of Barrett Design and Development reported that “not much has changed” from their initial plans to restore the front facades, remove both rear extensions, construct a new full-width extension, and add a one-story, full-width rooftop addition. The number of units in the works was reduced from seven to six. Changes were also made to plans for the rooftop addition and the rear yard. Construction should begin here in the next few weeks and will wrap, hopefully, in less than a year. Update: Pictured is a fresh rendering of the rear yard.
Makeover Coming to 121-3 Fort Greene Place [Brownstoner]
HOTD: 121-123 Fort Greene Place [Brownstoner] GMAP

By Emily | | Comment

Renovations Planned for 580 Carlton Avenue



The new owners of the seen-better-days house at 580 Carlton Avenue on a landmarked block in Prospect Heights are planning major upgrades. A couple of months ago a mock-up of a proposed extension was seen on the back of the building, and next week there’s going to be a Landmarks hearing on the proposed work. From the LPC meeting agenda: “An Italianate style wood frame rowhouse built c. prior to 1855 with later alterations. Application is to construct a rear yard addition, reconstruct the facades; and alter the front door and stoop.” The home was on the market for $499,000 earlier this year and ended up selling for $480,000. Thoughts on how much a top-to-bottom overhaul and rear extension might cost?
Something’s Afoot at Dilapidated Prospect Heights Home [Brownstoner]
HOTD: 580 Carlton Avenue [Brownstoner] GMAP P*Shark

By Emily | | Comment

Closing Bell: Tour Victorian Flatbush’s Japanese House



Cool news from Ditmas Park Blog: 131 Buckingham Road, the well-known Japanese-style home in Victorian Flatbush, will be open for a tour later this month. According to a BOTD post we ran on it, the “house is a large stucco covered box with Japanese brackets, bargeboards and an upturned roof. Chrysanthemums decorate the facade, and today the house is quite striking in the colors chosen to highlight the Japanese details, although period postcards show a more subdued use of color. The interior carried the Japanese theme further, with hand painted Japanese designs and carvings on the fireplaces and ceilings. The dining room had leaded glass windows with a dragon design.” The house has been in the same family since the early 1970s. The tour is scheduled for November 20th. More details at DPB.
Tour the Japanese House [Ditmas Park Blog]
BOTD: 131 Buckingham Road [Brownstoner]

By Emily | | Comment

Behold, the ‘Massive’ Penthouse Planned for 3rd Street



Tomorrow Landmarks is scheduled to have a hearing on a proposed rooftop addition to 627 3rd Street, a limestone beauty in the Park Slope Historic District that was a House of the Day last year. We’ve heard from one of the property’s neighbors, who is not at all pleased about the addition that’s in the works. She sent in the photos above, as well as the following note:

Here are some pictures of the proposed penthouse at 627 Third Street. It is 20 feet wide (sitting on party walls of 625 and 629), 9 feet to 14 feet high and 24 feet long. It is obviously quite massive, but this is only a wooden mockup for LPC’s review; the final would be brick and limestone. Notice that our chimney would disappear into the new wall and would reappear in mini form 15 feet closer to the front of the house. The last picture is taken from PPW on the park side. The mass and size of the structure makes it appear that it is sitting on the roof of the first house, but in reality it is the third house down!!

Think this will be a sore thumb for the Slope? GMAP

By Gabby | | Comment

UPDATE: Paul Robeson Theater is Landmarked



Today the Landmarks Preservation Commission will vote on the proposal to designate Fort Greene’s Paul Robeson Theater, previously the St. Casimir’s Roman Catholic Church, a landmark. According to the LPC, “Alterations to the building appear to be few, including the removal of some stained-glass windows and painting of the facade, but nevertheless this early Brooklyn church is a significant example of vernacular Gothic-style architecture and also an important reminder of the borough’s rich religious history.” Just this month DOB approved plans for remedial repair of the facade at 40 Greene Avenue. Update: The LPC voted to landmark the building. Click through for the designation report.
CB2 Gives OK To Landmark Paul Robeson Theater [Brownstoner]
LPC Considering Two Other Possible Landmarks [Brownstoner] GMAP DOB
(more…)

By Emily | | Comment