Can 4th Avenue’s Church of the Redeemer Be Saved?



When the Church of the Redeemer announced it would demolish its Gothic Revival structure at 24 4th Avenue at Pacific Street last year, the plan ignited community protest. Carolynn DiFiore Balmelle of the East Pacific Street Block Association updated us on the group’s continuing efforts to save the church. Since last July they have been fighting to repurpose the building, which was used as a school back in the ’70s. DiFiore Balmelle reached out to area preschools to gauge interest in moving into the structure; two schools seriously considered it and were given a tour last month. There’s still resistance from the church, though: Although they could charge an annual rent of $400,000 for the space, they are arguing that it would take $4 million to get the building back up to snuff. The church’s original plan was to demolish for a mixed-use building, including a new church and residential units. DiFiore Balmelle estimates that the existing structure, which needs its roof, electricity, and plumbing replaced, needs $2 million in repairs. She isn’t hopeful that the church will ultimately agree to rent out or repair the building. There also isn’t hope that Landmarks will step in to designate this building, which will soon be 160 years old. The community is holding another meeting to talk strategy, organize protest, and gain more support on Tuesday, April 30. It’ll be held at the YWCA at 30 3rd Avenue at 7 pm.

By Emily | | Comment

Inside a Windsor Terrace Church, Pre-Renovation



We took a trip out to Holy Name of Jesus Church at 245 Prospect Park West in Windsor Terrace to check out the interior, which has been dramatically altered throughout the years. The congregation is trying to raise upwards of $1 million for a full-scale restoration. The main focus of the project is remaking the altar area, including purchasing and installing a marble altarpiece by James Renwick (originally the focal point at a different Brooklyn church, now dissembled at a warehouse.) If the congregation raises more money, they will consider replacing the pews and the carpet and taking out the back wall. In any event, the Pepto-Bismol pink paint is definitely going. Click through to see interior photos of the church and read more details about the renovation plans. As of this week, the congregation has already raised $725,000 toward the project. Impressive.
Big Renovation for Windsor Terrace Church [Brownstoner]
Holy Name of Jesus Brooklyn Church Restoration Project [Facebook] (more…)

By Emily | | Comment

Big Renovation for Windsor Terrace Church



A historic church in Windsor Terrace, the Holy Name of Jesus Church at 245 Prospect Park West, is receiving a big historical restoration. And as a tipster puts it, “This isn’t just any church overhaul: Holy Name was architecturally desecrated in the 1970s, stripped of its beautiful original interiors, painted Pepto-Bismol PINK (it still is), and outfitted like a cross between a fern bar and the transporter room of the USS Enterprise.” The parish is now ready for a renovation and is focusing on a marble altarpiece by James Renwick as the focal point of the project. (Check out pictures of the altarpiece right here.) The church released a few images of proposed designs, although the final design will not be determined until the church knows how much money it can raise. A spokeswoman there says that if all goes according to plan they hope to finish the renovation in time for Christmas. If people are interested in contributing funds, they can call the Holy Name rectory at (718) 768-3071. They can also follow the whole project on Facebook.
Holy Name of Jesus Brooklyn Church Restoration Project [Facebook]

By Emily | | Comment

Suspicious Fire Damages Clinton Hill Church


The entrance and exterior of a Clinton Hill church built in 1891 and being used as a homeless shelter and hub for Occupy Sandy relief efforts were charred in a suspicious fire that started just before 4 am Sunday, many news outlets reported. Cans of gas intended for emergency generators were used to start the fire. The Church of St. Luke and St. Matthew is located at 520 Clinton Avenue. “Why do people do bad things?” the New York Daily News quoted Reverend Chris Ballard, the church’s curate, as saying. “We don’t know and our job is to try to work past that, try to find forgiveness. This is the season of it.” Sunday morning the choir sang outside the church, and services were held at a few blocks away at Brown Memorial Baptist Church. The church will hold Christmas Eve midnight mass tonight at 10 pm. Council Member Tish James sent out a press release stating that a reward of $1,000 is offered for information leading to the arrest of whoever set the fire.
Fire Damages Brooklyn Church [NY Times]
Historic Brooklyn Church Damaged in Early Morning Blaze [NY Daily News]
Photo by Vic Nicastro for New York Daily News

By Cate | | Comment

Occupy Sandy Operations in Pictures



GammaBlog shot these extremely cool, documentary-style photos of the Occupy Sandy warehouse operations that have taken over The Church of St. Luke and St. Matthew Episcopal church in Clinton Hill. Click through to the original story to see all the photos. Pretty impressive — both the setup and the photos.
Occupy Sandy’s Holy Warehouse [GammaBlog]

By Cate | | Comment

An Update on the Crown Heights Church Cornice



The metal cornice is gone at the the St. Teresa of Avila Catholic Church on the corner of Classon Avenue and Sterling Place in Crown Heights. It was removed with a crane a few days ago, after pieces were dangling off the building due to the storm. A reader in last week’s post noted that the damaged tower has been in poor shape for several years, due to constant problems with pigeons and some grating that fell on the roof. We hear that this parish does not have lots of money, and this particular structure isn’t under landmarks protection. What a shame. See a few more shots after the jump.
Roof Collapsing at Crown Heights Church [Brownstoner] (more…)

By Emily | | Comment

Roof Collapsing at Crown Heights Church



This was the scene this afternoon at the St. Teresa of Avila Catholic Church on the corner of Classon Avenue and Sterling Place. Police taped off the entire block and looked like they were waiting for the portion of the roof to fall off. This church was built in 1905; the twin towers have clock faces on the right and the carillon of ten bells on the left. It’s the right tower with the structural damage. See a BOTD post here. See more pictures after the jump, including a dramatic shot of the collapse happening on the other side of the building. (more…)

By Emily | | Comment

Repair Work Continues at Lightning-Damaged Church



A reader sent in this photo of the repair work ongoing at Christ Church in Cobble Hill, where lightning struck on July 26, damaging the tower and killing local resident state Assistant Attorney General Richard Schwartz. Traffic at the corner of Kane and Clinton remains completely blocked with the intersection closed to all, our tipster said. No one is allowed on the south side of the sidewalk. Two large cranes remain on the scene.
Christ Church Steeples to Come Down [Brownstoner] GMAP
Lightning Kills Man, Damages Church in Cobble Hill [Brownstoner]
Lightning Hit Brooklyn Last Night, Caused One Fatality [Brownstoner]

By Cate | | Comment

Christ Church Steeples to Come Down


There’s more bad news from Cobble Hill’s Christ Church, which was damaged in a lightning storm and consequently killed one neighborhood resident. Now it looks like the four steeples rising above the bell tower will have to be torn down, The New York Times reported. Yesterday, one steeple already came down (they are about 70 feet high!) and the others are expected to be removed in the next few days. The lightning also caused roof damage, threatening the interiors as well. A church official said it is not yet clear whether insurance will cover a full restoration. The Gothic Revival church was designed by Richard Upjohn, creator of Trinity Church in Manhattan. According to the Times, the church was “damaged by a fire in 1939 and all but six windows of the nave were destroyed, including a Tiffany window depicting the Adoration of the Magi. The church, though, was rebuilt and designated a city landmark in 1969.”
Lightning Shatters Tower at a 19th-Century Church [NY Times]
Lightning Kills Man, Damages Church in Cobble Hill [Brownstoner]
Lightning Hit Brooklyn Last Night, Caused One Fatality [Brownstoner]

By Cate | | Comment

Walkabout: You’d have to be a saint…Part 2



(St. Peter Claver Church and Fr. Bernard Quinn, from frquinn.org)

African American Catholics have not had an easy time of it in the Church. Historically speaking, black folks have been Catholics since Catholics have been in the Americas, although certainly not sitting as equals in the pews. A few black Catholics have had a great deal of influence in the American Church, in spite of racism and intolerance, and in the last installment we met Pierre and Juliet Toussaint of New York, and, a century later, the Healy brothers, originally from Georgia. The 19th century ended with little progress being made in the Church to integrate black Catholics into the growing fold of American Catholicism.

In 1916, a group of African American Catholics came together as the Committee for the Advancement of Colored Catholics. They were seeking equal care by Catholic organizations such as the Knights of Columbus, for black veterans returning from World War I. The group was interested in opening a dialogue with American bishops, who administered Church policy, to urge them to denounce discrimination, and to meet with black Catholics. They stated in their appeal: “at present we are neither a part of the colored world (Protestant), nor are we generally treated as full-fledged Catholics.” It would take the actions of a few extraordinary people to bring the Church around. One of these people was here in Brooklyn, and this Walkabout is his story. He was Monsignor Bernard J. Quinn. (more…)

By Montrose Morris | | Comment

Walkabout: You’d have to be a saint to put up with this



(Pierre and Juliet Toussaint, of New York, prominent African American Catholics)

Yesterday’s Building of the Day was the St. Peter Claver School, located in Bedford Stuyvesant. Researching the building introduced me to Reverend Bernard Quinn, the pastor of St. Peter Claver Church, and a tireless advocate in the Catholic Church for African Americans. He lived and worked during a time when black folk of the Catholic persuasion didn’t have that many friends, not even in the church itself, and as someone who is black, and was raised as a Catholic, I found his story quite interesting and inspiring. Since he was a Brooklyn character, I thought that I would introduce him, and the church community that he founded here in Brownstone Brooklyn, to the Brownstoner audience. It doesn’t matter what you believe or don’t believe. Sometimes there are those individuals in history who are just, well….saints.

A little background first. As long as there have been Catholics in this country, there have been black Catholics, even if they were in chains. The Spanish, especially, were very zealous in converting their African slaves to Catholicism, as were, to a lesser degree, the French. Most of us are passingly familiar with the cultures of the Catholic South, especially in New Orleans, but also in Florida and elsewhere in the South, where Spain, France, Portugal and Africa met. This was true not just in America, but also in the Caribbean, Central and South America. The blending of Catholicism and African religion has given us Vodun and Santeria, a fascinating subject in of itself. (more…)

By Montrose Morris | | Comment

The Upstater: Churches for Sale in Upstate New York


Think of the real estate blog Upstater as Brownstoner for the Catskills and Hudson Valley. We’re combing the counties south of Albany, east of Connecticut and west of the PA border for upstate New York real estate that has a special appeal to New Yorkers (especially because you can buy an entire farm house for the price of a studio apartment in Brooklyn). From now on, we’ll be sharing some of our finds in a weekly column here on Brownstoner, and for our debut column we took a look at churches for sale north of New York City. One is a converted chapel, ready for roosting. The others are waiting to be reinvented as residences.

2847 Atlantic Avenue in the tiny hamlet of Stottville, NY, just outside of Hudson, is the cream of this week’s crop. Beautifully renovated, already fully converted to residential but with many of the most impressive church elements preserved.

Lots more on the jump…
(more…)

By upstater | | Comment

Williamsburg Church Sells, New Owner Plans Conversion



Yesterday the brokerage MNS sent out a press release saying the firm had handled the sale of Williamsburg’s St. Vincent De Paul Church, which is on North 6th between Bedford and Driggs. The building sold for $13.7 million, and while the buyer wasn’t identified (the sale hasn’t made it to public records yet), a rep for MNS told us the new owner is planning a residential conversion but there’s no time line set for the project yet. The Brooklyn Paper mentioned the sale in an article a couple weeks ago about how workers were removing historical details from the church, like stained-glass windows and a bronze bell, on behalf of the Brooklyn Diocese in advance of the property being transferred to the new owner. The church isn’t a landmark. GMAP

By Gabby | | Comment

Baptist Church Looking to Team With Developer



A couple weeks ago an $8 million listing appeared for the Baptist church on Schermerhorn Street and 3rd Avenue, but a story in today’s Journal says the congregation is looking to work with a developer on a mixed-use conversion rather than simply selling the building off. New Baptist Temple’s pastor says the church doesn’t intend to relocate but, instead, find a builder that would construct a residential addition and help renovate the church, which was damaged by a fire last year. Ideally, the congregation would stay put and the church—which is on the National Register but isn’t a city landmark—wouldn’t be demolished. However, it’s unclear how costly it would be to repair the property. Ofer Cohen, president of the commercial brokerage TerraCRG, is quoted as saying that while there’s plenty of demand for condos or rentals in the area, it would probably “be cheaper to knock it down” rather than rebuild.
Church Thinks Mixed-Use [WSJ]
Baptist Church on Schermerhorn For Sale [Brownstoner] GMAP
Photo via PropertyShark

By Gabby | | Comment

Baptist Church on Schermerhorn For Sale



The Baptist church on Schermerhorn Street and 3rd Avenue has been put on the market for $8 million. So far the listing is short on details aside from noting that the property represents a “development opportunity.” The building, which is on the National Register but isn’t a city landmark, was damaged by a fire last year. We’re interested in knowing whether the sales pitch involves a conversion or razing but have yet to hear back from the brokers.
Fire at Boerum Hill Baptist Temple GMAP
Photo via PropertyShark

By Gabby | | Comment

Sheepshead Bay Steeples Will Remain


Today The Eagle points to a Courier Life article that says the steeples on Sheepshead Bay’s 142-year-old United Methodist Church will not be demolished. The church’s pastor says the congregation brought in a new contractor who presented an affordable plan for preserving the steeples. The news follows previous reports that said the structures were a safety hazard and the congregation didn’t have enough money to keep them intact. The Courier Life story also notes that the renovation will be the first the church has seen in more than 85 years.
Steeples Saved! [Courier Life]
Historic Sheepshead Bay Church To Save Its Leaning Steeples [Eagle]
Steeple Demolition Uncontroversial in Sheepshead [Brownstoner]
Here is the Church, and There Go the Steeples [Brownstoner] GMAP
Photo by wallyg.

By Gabby | | Comment

Steeple Demolition Uncontroversial in Sheepshead


This weekend The Times took a look at Sheepshead Bay’s United Methodist, where the congregation says it will have to take down the steeples on the neighborhood’s oldest church because they’re a safety hazard and would be too costly to repair. According to the article, the impending demolition has not been met with much outcry in the neighborhood: “There were no protests, heated community meetings or fund-raising campaigns to save the steeples. That quiet, said Ned Berke, the editor of Sheepshead Bites, revealed just how fragmented and disconnected from history Sheepshead Bay had become. ‘Sheepshead’s changing demographics are an ongoing obstacle to communication,’ Mr. Berke wrote in an e-mail. ‘It really throws a wrench in any attempt to preserve the building and its history.’” The story also notes that the church’s congregation has declined drastically over the years and its “officials said the decision to tear down the spires was not an easy one. It was made only after years of meetings with architects, engineers and city officials.”
A Neighborhood’s Steeples Are Set to Disappear Quietly [NY Times]
Here is the Church, and There Go the Steeples [Brownstoner] GMAP
Photo by wallyg.

By Gabby | | Comment

New Housing to Replace Bay Ridge Church



Bay Ridge Journal reports that “the charming Salam Arabic Lutheran Church building, at 345 Ovington Avenue between 3rd and 4th Avenues in Bay Ridge, is scheduled for demolition, to be replaced by a 5-story, 25-unit residential development…Salam, originally known as Salem Danish Evangelical Lutheran Church, after a church in Copenhagen, Denmark, was renamed after being acquired by an Arabic congregation in 1995. The Arabic congregation, which says it can’t afford to maintain the building, is sharing space at Our Saviour’s Lutheran Church at 80th Street and Fourth Avenue.” According to Property Shark, the church dates back to 1920; the DOB application for the new construction is here.
Developer Buys, Will Demolish Salam Arabic Church [Bay Ridge Journal] GMAP
Photo from Property Shark.

By Gabby | | Comment

Here is the Church, and There Go the Steeples



Yesterday Sheepshead Bites had a post on a story it’s been tracking concerning how the current congregation of the church at 3087 Ocean Avenue intends to tear down the steeples on its 142-year-old building. An organization called the Bay Improvement Group (BIG) is advocating for their retention and tried at one point to convince the church’s owners to pursue landmark status: “We at BIG tried in the early 1990′s pleading with their Board of Directors/Trustees to Landmark the Church and they were sadly, ignorantly afraid of ‘Landmark status’ even though we tried to persuade them with experts in Church preservation, Engineers & Architects and myself, as an Attorney, to explain the great help they would have in obtaining Landmark status. They could have received State, City, Federal and private grants to restore the Church!” Today The Daily News picks up on the story, and has a quote from the church’s pastor about how the steeples are unsafe and the congregation can’t afford to renovate them: “‘We are concerned really about safety,’ said Pastor Jay Kyung Kim, who said the spires are cracked and leaning precariously. ‘If it falls down, it’s a tragedy.’ He hopes to eventually raise the cash to build new steeples, but has no idea how long that will take.” Sad stuff.
BIG Pleads For Savior Of Methodist Church [Sheepshead Bites]
Historic Steeples of 142-Year-Old United Methodist Church Will be Torn Down [NY Daily News]
Photo from Sheepshead Bites.

By Gabby | | Comment