« PLG Gets Its First Organic Market Flatbush Rezoning Can't Come Soon Enough »

June 2, 2009

Walkabout with Montrose: Standing at the Door

Since the day man figured out how to roll a stone in front of his cave from the inside, we’ve had doors. Doors are security, doors are defensible. A doorway is the passageway from the outside into someone’s home, someone’s business, someone’s house of worship. In obvious, practical terms, it’s how you enter the building. But let’s go psychological and metaphorical here for a moment. A door is also your first impression as to the interior of the building. How that door looks, what it’s made of, the color, and the size, the hardware, the entire entranceway, all these elements also provide our subconscious with clues as to what the builder or owner would like you to think about them. Are you meant to be impressed with wealth, status, piety, thrift, cleanliness, security, or conversely, a lessening of circumstance, sloth, carelessness, or worst, a lack of taste? We speak of a doorway between life and death, the door to your heart. So, what does that door look like?

The photo essay today depicts some of the thousands of late 19th and early 20th century doors in Brooklyn. Most are from row houses, some from churches, banks, apartment buildings, private houses and the final doors for some well-heeled people – the mausoleum doors in Green-Wood Cemetery. Some doors feature gorgeous hardware that costs a fortune to replicate today, some of it goes unrestored and unnoticed by their owners and tenants. Some have ornate glass or impressive ironwork, or fantastically detailed wood carvings. Some doors are just massive, some hardly even noticeable in their elaborate framing. Some are classic, tall Victorian doors that instantly evoke a period feeling, others were deliberately designed to recall a far more distant time and place. Like the other detailing and ornament in Brownstone Brooklyn, doors are beautiful examples of the philosophy and mindset of a society that valued beauty along with practicality. There are no Home Depot doors here - take a look.

Of course, every door doesn’t really always mean something, and every door does not mirror the circumstances of the inhabitants, especially today. Sometimes you just take what’s given, and whether or not that door keeps intruders out becomes much more important than trumpeting one’s social status. My horrible replacement, no style, heavy wooden door was put in place when my block resembled the OK Corral, something it no longer does. I understand that, and am glad that while it’s here, it’s still protecting my property. But the minute I can, that door is landfill, and a more period appropriate door is going in, and the original dimensions of the doorway are going to be put back. I can’t wait. I think my house will be happy, too. Like the architect who designed the house, I would like my door to say something more positive about me.




Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.brownstoner.com/mte/mt-tb.cgi/9992

Comments

Yawn..

The What

Someday this war is gonna end...

Posted by: Return of The What at June 2, 2009 10:33 AM

You had to read, or at least look, at it to be bored......gotcha!

Posted by: Montrose Morris at June 2, 2009 10:37 AM

The What wouldn't know a nice door if it slammed him in the ass.

Posted by: daveinbedstuy at June 2, 2009 10:38 AM

I'm amazed, What, that you don't have rabid opinions about doors - they're great metaphors for closed minds.

Posted by: Arkady at June 2, 2009 10:38 AM

What PWNED by Montrose. ROTFLMMFAO

Posted by: daveinbedstuy at June 2, 2009 10:38 AM

Fantastic!
They don't make them like that any more (except for restorations)!
Brooklyn brownstone doors are beautiful. I particularly like the original wood and glass storm doors, like the ones pictured. I hope the owners of these buildings appreciate the rarity of these handmade objects, many made from wood that is no longer available.

Posted by: sam at June 2, 2009 10:38 AM

"You had to read, or at least look, at it to be bored......gotcha!

Posted by: Montrose Morris at June 2, 2009 10:37 AM"

No sweetie I been looking at those doors all my life. I used to walk in and out of one everyday. Now change your panties...

The What

Someday this war is gonna end...

Posted by: Return of The What at June 2, 2009 10:41 AM

pssst....I think this'll be one of the best chapters.

Posted by: daveinbedstuy at June 2, 2009 10:41 AM

Beautiful post Montrose.

This is a sore subject for me as the original doors were removed from my home and are now on my list of things I need to make right again.

Posted by: TownhouseLady at June 2, 2009 10:42 AM

Stuy Hts and those French Gothics in CHN were terrific, thanks MM.

Posted by: DeLepp at June 2, 2009 10:42 AM

THL...we should have a conversation...I just went through that decision myself.

Posted by: daveinbedstuy at June 2, 2009 10:44 AM

Beautiful write-up and pictures, Montrose. Thank you.

Posted by: Biff Champion at June 2, 2009 10:46 AM

"Like the other detailing and ornament in Brownstone Brooklyn, doors are beautiful examples of the philosophy and mindset of a society that valued beauty along with practicality".

Montrose;

I have to pick a bone with you about this statement. What these doors and the other ornamentation of brwnstones deonstrate is the WEALTH of Victorian Brooklyn. It was a wealth that could lavish money on such ornamentation.

It is a cheap shot to pick on"Home Depot" doors. For folks of modest means, these doors serve very well. I'm sorry, but the statement above has a sort of "let them eat cake" feel to it.

Otherwise, great write-up, as usual.

Posted by: benson at June 2, 2009 10:49 AM

Thank you, gorgeous photos and essay. I am obsessed with doors, and these are just beautiful.

Posted by: Maly at June 2, 2009 10:51 AM

Thanks Montrose, interesting as usual!
I have lived in apartment buildings since college. Think that having a door that opened on to the street would take some getting used to again, if I were ever to buy a house.

Posted by: etson at June 2, 2009 10:54 AM

"It is a cheap shot to pick on "Home Depot" doors. For folks of modest means, these doors serve very well. I'm sorry, but the statement above has a sort of "let them eat cake" feel to it."

benson, I see your point and also feel there is often a lot of condescension on this site about people doing mid or low-end renovations. However, I think in the context above, Montrose was simply making the Home Depot reference as an innocent comparison between today's standard and common doors versus the gorgeous and ornate versions above - perhaps in a "they sure don't make 'em like that" kind of way.

Posted by: Biff Champion at June 2, 2009 11:04 AM

i'm with what here....

Posted by: randolph at June 2, 2009 11:05 AM

i used to live in a loft building in tribeca where we kept the front door (and the entrance hallway that you could see through the glass) really beat up and grungy on purpose. that way no one would ever know that each residence was the opposite of beat up and grungy. not a single burglary since 1971 when it turned coop.

Posted by: winthropst at June 2, 2009 11:06 AM

benson! Puhlease! Even in less expensive homes, there was pride of craftsmenship when these homes were built. I've been in tenement buildings that had beautiful wood panel doors- cheap for the period, maybe, and not fancy, but beautifully crafted and pleasing to look at. Home Depot sells mass produced doors, out of cheap materials, with very little regard or eye for design- this is not a "let them eat cake comment" it was a simple out and out factual comment.

In fact, even tenement buildings were not the fedders boxes of today. many of them had nice cornices, doorways and windows. There was always some design elements- it was the way things were done then. Look at how beautiful old factory buildings can be- the archways, the brickwork- that was the mindset of the time. And Home Depot (which both MM and I happily frequent) is not of that mindset.

Posted by: bxgrl at June 2, 2009 11:08 AM

Benson, not all of these doors are from wealthy homes. Some are solidly middle class, I've got shots from what were, even back then, not the homes of the wealthy. A couple of the apt buildings, some of which I didn't put on flickr, as I have at least twice as many photographs as shown, would have been considered even lower than middle class. They also had attractive wood or glass and iron doors. Point being, the mindset was different then. Beauty was as much a requisite as function.

While I certainly understand that Home Depot doors are cheaper than period or custom replacements, and that not everyone is aware of, can afford to replace, or cares about having a period appropriate door, that doesn't mean I have to accept them as suitable substitutes. If I wanted to be ultra snarky, I could have shown about a hundred shots of HD style doors, 99% of which do their buildings no joy, they are, after all, everywhere. My intent was to celebrate original period doors, nothing more. My door wouldn't even rate a Home Depot moniker, so I can't throw stones. I know it's expensive to replace them. That doesn't mean I have to like them.

Posted by: Montrose Morris at June 2, 2009 11:13 AM

Well said, bxgrl!

Posted by: Arkady at June 2, 2009 11:14 AM

arkady- love your book. Have you even been to Tinsel Trading in Manhattan for trim?

Posted by: bxgrl at June 2, 2009 11:18 AM

I meant to say, "perhaps in a "they sure don't make 'em like that ANYMORE" kind of way".

Regardless, bxgrl, what you say is true. Home Depot obviously serves a huge market and I think the store's name has simply come to represent a symbol of the differences between how most development is done these days versus the past. Let's face it, they really don't build anything like they used to unless one wants to pay an arm and a leg for the highest quality materials. And most people can't afford to do that, especially these days. It sounds like Home Depot is to blame for it all, but really, just who is building the Taj Mahals, the Angor Wats, and even the mid-nineteenth century quality brownstones anymore?

Posted by: Biff Champion at June 2, 2009 11:21 AM

biff- we don't even have the number of craftsmen who used to do this kind of work. Mass production killed so many skills, and we've lost a vast store of knowledge and experience. That's why a good craftsman today is worth so much- but when they were making doors like these, they were the rule, not the exception.

Posted by: bxgrl at June 2, 2009 11:40 AM

bxgrl, good point.

Posted by: Biff Champion at June 2, 2009 11:41 AM

Folks;

You point out that "back in the days" even the front doors of tenements were grand affairs. Need I remind you that the workers who BUILT those doors LIVED in those tenements???? For guys who had to live in a 6-story walk-up tenement, with a shared bathroom, no hot water and no bath, who worked for a pittance of a wage in dangerous conditions, with no workmen's comp., no unemployment insurance, no health insurance and paid vacation, the wonder of looking at those beautiful doors must have faded fast. I guess we should thank the builders of these tenements for this small favor to their workers.

The economics of construction has changed since the Victorian days. Guys who work in construction want to make a decent living. Resources that were once plentiful and cheap in this country are no longer that.

I still maintain that it was a cheap shot to compare these doors to those at Home Depot. I don't think folks of wealth shop at Home Depot. Why not compare these Victorian doors to those built for today's wealth (say, the townhomes that were built on State Street).

Posted by: benson at June 2, 2009 11:41 AM

benson- as usual you take words and twist the intent and meaning and make the discussion totally into something else. I'm not going to engage you in this except to tell you i think your comment about taking a cheap shot applies much more to you than to MM. And we were not discussing the socio-economic problems of the day but the aesthetics of architecture.

Posted by: bxgrl at June 2, 2009 11:49 AM

Montrosse, have you done an essay on stoops yet? Lets have a stoop tour of inner Brooklyn. Doubles, singles, doglegged, wooden, tall, short, etc.

Posted by: sam at June 2, 2009 11:52 AM

Bxgrl;

WOW!!!

OK, I'll make it up to all. I'm offering to install Fiberama awnings on your place, free of charge.

Posted by: benson at June 2, 2009 11:54 AM

benson- and I will happily cook you dinner! (Of course I AM a horrible cook....:-)

Posted by: bxgrl at June 2, 2009 11:59 AM

Benson, as Bxgrl said, my essay and photos were meant to celebrate the architecture and craftsmanship of the day. I am well aware of the socio-economics of the past, as well as today's. But beauty is beauty. When I admire great interior detail, such as was on the PLG house tour, I know the original builders were probably underpaid, and that underpaid immigrant maids from Ireland were toiling to make that wood gleam, and that black servants were slaving away in the kitchen. That's a fact of the past. I celebrate all of their efforts by bringing them to people's attention, so they can be preserved for future passersby to admire, and so that their work will be cherished by more homeowners, not discarded. Their work has outlasted the names of the more wealthy owners, and I, in my small way, am paying homage. No more, no less.

Gotta run out, but can continue later. I'm glad the doors are a popular topic. I'm tempted to say it lights my fire, but that would be an AWFUL historic and cultural reference, wouldn't it?

Posted by: Montrose Morris at June 2, 2009 12:07 PM

I hate people who know more about my neighborhood than I do. I wish I had paid more attention to things like this. Instead, I skipped school and went to the movies on Fulton Street. It is too late for me to get a proper education and I avoid learning something new even when it is offered to me for free.

Posted by: ghettoazzpnkbtch at June 2, 2009 12:39 PM

MM, I've enjoyed all your walkabouts but this one may be my favorite so far. I'm truly looking forward to what you've got up your sleeve next! Towards that end, I ditto Sam's suggestion of stoops. Also wish to add in my own request for your take on gates, fences and balconies.

ghettoazz- right on!:->

Posted by: Brooklynista at June 2, 2009 1:00 PM

Benson, poor people can afford to *leave their original doors alone* and not put in new Home Depot doors.

Montrose, I love old doors. I love their inexplicable proportions. So tall and hooded.

Posted by: mopar at June 2, 2009 2:24 PM

THL and Dave, or anyone else, how do you replace replacement doors? You find salvage doors with the exact measurement of the opening, or how does it work?

Posted by: mopar at June 2, 2009 3:21 PM

That's what I did, mopar. I had a 60s or 70s style door with a nice transom and nicely done fluted casings on the side that were put in to replace the full height double doors seen in MM's pics. Since the transom and the casings look really nice I decided to just replace the door and not do the whole thing over. Doing the whole thing over would have been the right choise if my house was in the $2MM+ price range but it is not and, despite the rantings of Team Bull members, won't be soon. Doing the whole thing over with new doors would be $10k +

Do I bought this style door from this company and it was an exact fit...

http://www.archantiquities.com/doors/26068053Photos%20021.jpg.php

Posted by: daveinbedstuy at June 2, 2009 3:43 PM

Montrose:

Very nice post today. One things doors do is teach kids lessons, which happened for me growing up in Crown Heights during the 1950s and 1960s.

At the door to the bank building at Nostrand and Eastern Parkway is inscribed "A Journey Of A Thousand Miles Begins With But A Single Step" -- a Chinese proverb, I believe, no doubt quoted to encourage thrift.

The words bore their way into my small brain and I repeated them in a grade-school speech about the importance of learning. My teacher was very impressed by my sophistication. Little did she know I picked it up from a building where I kept my nickels and dimes!

And by the way, there's a famous poster showing Amsterdam's painted doors. Hook up with a local graphic artist and make one for Brooklyn -- please!

Nostalgic on Park Avenue

Posted by: NOP at June 2, 2009 5:40 PM

Dave, thanks so much for the info. And the door looks really nice! I would not guess it was not original. And the price is right. Nice going.

Posted by: mopar at June 2, 2009 6:15 PM

Post a comment

Please be patient while your comment is published. It may take a moment.

Latest Restaurant Additions