« Dolkart Down on Prospects for "Fringe Areas" Rental of the Day: 383 Carlton Avenue »
November 19, 2008
Wednesday Food & Drink Round-Up

Now Closed: Trout Swims with the Fishes
102 Smith Street (at Pacific Street)
"Boerum Hill’s dumpy oasis, Trout, closed on Sunday... A plan to develop the corner Trout occupied on Smith and Pacific also fell through after two years of negotiations, [owner Jim Mamary] said, but he assured us that Pacifico is safe (and still serving margaritas). As for that oyster bar planned to go with Black Mountain Wine House, Mamary today declared it 'dead in the water.'" [Grub Street]
This Week's Opening: Vinegar Hill House
72 Hudson Avenue, Vinegar Hill
As we reported back in September, former Freemans chef Jean Adamson has been converting the former butcher shop at 72 Hudson Avenue into a restaurant. According to New York magazine, it's opening this week as Vinegar Hill House: "Adamson describes her menu as Moosewood Cookbook–ish in its focus on grains, legumes, and vegetables, which are intended to supplement smaller portions of protein. Her fish will be sustainable and her meats broken down from whole animals procured from Fleisher’s, the upstate cult butcher, all cooked in the wood-burning oven. Also on offer: a raw bar, an American-cheese-and-homemade-cracker board, and $9 classic cocktails—liquor license pending."
After the jump: The secret to getting seated instantly at Al Di La, a taste of Naples in Williamsburg, and a waiter gets "repeatedly stabbed" with a fork at the newly renovated Kellogg's Diner...
Want a Table at Al Di La Without a Wait?
248 5th Avenue, Park Slope; (718) 783-4565
Go at lunch time. Al Di La quietly started serving midday meals last week, so grab a seat before everybody finds out. Chowhound jinx reports: "The menu is quite truncated from the dinner menu, but still plenty of yummy stuff to be had. I was a bit disappointed that they didn't have the malfatti or the beet raviolis (as I had a friend with me from out of town, and had been raving to her about the malfatti.) But she was perfectly happy with the butternut squash tortellini and I with wild mushrooms and swiss chard over creamy polenta.... Only a few other tables taken, but I imagine the word will be out now!"
A Taste of Naples: Motorino
319 Graham Avenue (near Devoe Street), Williamsburg; (718) 599-8899
CHOW's Outer Borough Digest has good things to say about the new Williamsburg pizzeria, Motorino: "[Chowhound] wew classifies it as 'near soft crust strictish Neo style' and finds it even better than well-regarded competitors La Pizza Fresca and Una Pizza Napoletana. He describes an exemplary crust out of the wood oven, boasting 'a touch of crisp on the very bottom that dissolved as I ate,' and sauce with just enough salt and a pleasing zing." And Tasting Table recommends picking up a bottle from nearby Blue Angel Wines on your way there, as Motorino is presently BYOB.
Fork Stabbing at Kellogg's Diner
Metropolitan and Union avenues, Williamsburg
Kellogg's Diner has a sleek new look, but staffers still have to watch their backs: "A drunken maniac turned a [this] Williamsburg diner upside down yesterday when he went on a profanity-laced tirade, threw a plate of pancakes, and repeatedly stabbed a waiter with a fork," reports the New York Post via Eater.
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.brownstoner.com/mte/mt-tb.cgi/7274
Comments
TROUT had all the potential in the world. Great Location. Great Space.It was obvious the owners did not care about the place over the past year. The outside and inside was always dirty food in consistent. Pacifico is a joke as well. Dirty and rude staff.When you walk by both they are filthy and undesirable. They have the Pacific Pizza its never open it just makes no business sense the way they ran it.
Posted by: THAL at November 19, 2008 11:47 AM
Trout's owners piss me off. Gravy was an ok place... the food/price ratio wasn't bad. And, they had a few really good things, like the red-skinned cheddar smashed potatoes. Then, they took the crappy part (Trout) and combined it with Gravy, forming Big Trout. Zero redeemable qualities for Big Trout. AND... they closed Pacific Pizza, which actually made great pies. That's the thing I don't get... it was always busy, and everyone I spoke to really liked it. Then, they converted the pizza place into an entrance for the overrated Pacifico.
Posted by: broadwayron at November 19, 2008 11:52 AM
glad pecifico is safe
Posted by: troll at November 19, 2008 11:55 AM
Amazing and a shame that all those parcels at Trout/Pacifico and adjoining lots were not redeveloped in last decade. Not too much hope now. Prime spot very underutilized.
PS - Hoyt Street neighbor's are going to be happy about no Oyster Bar (unless of course he's substituting a sports bar).
Posted by: Petebklyn at November 19, 2008 12:06 PM
Re: Fork stabbing
The waiter must've described their menu as "plenty of yummy stuff to be had" and, hence - like anyone who's older than 8 but still describes restaurant dishes as "yummy" - had it comming.
Don't care what you little girls have to say about Trout, I'm very sad to see it go. The dirt and grit was part its charm.
Posted by: heck_of_a_job_brownie at November 19, 2008 12:08 PM
"The dirt and grit was part its charm."
Agreed there. I'll eat off a barn floor if the food is good.
But the food SUCKED.
Posted by: Prodigal_Son at November 19, 2008 12:20 PM
The secret to getting a table immediately at Al Di La is to walk in on a thursday at 9pm with no reservation ... at least, that's how my fiancee and I did it a couple of weeks ago.
Posted by: cwbuecheler at November 19, 2008 12:35 PM
um...buechler
Walking in without a reservation is how everyone does it.
They don't -take- reservations.
Posted by: Prodigal_Son at November 19, 2008 12:42 PM
Trout had the looks and food of a tacky seaside restaurant that would fit in more in Coney Island than on Smith Street. I went there for brunch once and got the heebie jeebies just passing it after that. Good riddance!
Posted by: Biff Champion at November 19, 2008 12:48 PM
By "I went there for brunch once and got the heebie jeebies just passing it after that" I meant after passing the restaurant, not after passing the lunch, but, come to think of it, I could have been referring to both.
Posted by: Biff Champion at November 19, 2008 12:50 PM
To be fair, Biff, their brunch at one point was their peak. Way back when they opened, the brunch was excellent, even with the "dirty, grimy charm" .
Posted by: Prodigal_Son at November 19, 2008 12:56 PM
the texican omelette will be missed...
Posted by: ProspectHeightsGuy at November 19, 2008 1:02 PM
too bad pacifico didn't close with it. that place is digusting, and the food is horrible. That space has a lot of potential to become something Habana Outpost / Gowanus Yacht Club-esque. But it wont without some major help!
Posted by: kjp216 at November 19, 2008 1:15 PM
I wish the owners of all there terrible restaurants on smith would go out of business (trout pacifico union cafe patois ETC) they all SUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: gkw at November 19, 2008 1:27 PM
Al Di La seems to be a favorite among the Brownstoner's readers. You little Britney groupies love your food bland and non-threatening, with a dash of overhyped, dontcha?
Another word people need to be stabbed with a fork for using: brunch. What's next, spoiling champagne by pouring orange juice in it?
Posted by: heck_of_a_job_brownie at November 19, 2008 1:27 PM
Who ever ate anything at Trout anyway? It was just a great semi-outdoor drinking establishment. Very sad to it go.
Posted by: Remsen at November 19, 2008 1:55 PM
"Who ever ate anything at Trout anyway?"
Me, unfortunately...
Posted by: Biff Champion at November 19, 2008 2:02 PM
The rabbit I had at Al Di La wasn't bland. It was pretty non-threatening though.
Posted by: cwbuecheler at November 19, 2008 2:07 PM
That bit of Smith & Pacific has been a Bermuda triangle for culinary hopes. Here's hoping that something with minimally decent food opens there.
Posted by: Brooklyn Chicken at November 19, 2008 2:58 PM

Post a comment
Please be patient while your comment is published. It may take a moment.