« New Plans Revealed for Windsor Terrace Playground Gardening on the Mind »

April 21, 2008

Brooklyn Gets 5 Nods in TONY's Eat Out Awards

tony-eat-out-04-2008.jpg
We're pretty late to the party on this one, but in last week's Time Out New York, five Brooklyn establishments got shout-outs in the mag's annual eat out awards. Three Brooklyn restaurants/bars were singled out in the readers' choice section, and two in the critics' choice. These are the places that nabbed awards, along with TONY verbiage on the spots:

Readers' Choice Picks:

Best neighborhood bistro
Bar Tabac
Other nominees: L’Absinthe, La Sirène, Régate
Though bistros sprout up as routinely as Duane Reades, this convivial den of steak frites, laid-back Brooklynites and Francophile charm is foremost in your affections. Tabac is Boerum Hill’s beacon because it embodies the bistro ideal: Everyone is welcome. Kitschy Pernod signs, weathered wood and brass aplenty—not to mention the hot live jazz—help set the warm and festive mood. Hefty portions of French comfort classics, such as coq au vin and trout amandine, are superaffordable and, most importantly, available long past midnight. 128 Smith Street, Boerum Hill.

Best new Brooklyn restaurant
Alchemy
Other nominees: Elementi, Fette Sau, Hibino
Medieval alchemists tried turning lead into gold. Park Slope’s Alchemy transformed a hardware store into a London-style gastropub, and you’ve deemed it Brooklyn’s preeminent new eatery. The formula is simple: Fill a brick-and-weathered-wood room with deep booths and filament bulbs, toss in locally brewed beer, add a secluded backyard and fashion lofty pub grub that rivals the fare at the Spotted Pig. Curried fried calamari and tempura-crunchy fish-and-chips appease the hunger of Brooklynites from lunch to late night, while Guinness-flavored pancakes set the gold standard at breakfast. 56 Fifth Avenue, Park Slope.

Best new bar
Huckleberry Bar
Other nominees: B Flat, The Gutter, Smith & Mills
The name says it all: To be a huckleberry is to be the right one for the job, and Huckleberry Bar is just that. Owners Andrew Boggs and Stephanie Schneider have created an experience that will satisfy any boozer’s desire: choice beers, an ace wine selection, serious cocktails and respectable eats. Every detail, down to a DJ who adjusts the soundtrack to fit the crowd and hour, is tailored to give you what you want. They got it right—and you rewarded them. 588 Grand Street, Williamsburg.

After the jump, Brooklyn's two critics' choice winners....

Critics' Choice Picks:

Best melting-pot cuisine
Korhogo 126
Fusion-fueled restaurants have been with us for a long time, for better and for worse. Often the greatest successes are the combinations that aren’t forced, but are rather logical conclusions of shared histories. Korhogo 126—which served straight-up Gallic cuisine when it was Bouillabaisse 126—is such a place. Chef Abdhul Traore, from the former French colony Côte d’Ivoire, effortlessly blends the foods of his fatherland with classic techniques and flavors: France’s beloved escargots are cooked in a spiced Pernod–red wine sauce, and seafood stewed in a lightly peppered tomato broth pays homage to legendary Ivorian and French fish soups. Food this delicious can’t excuse colonialism, but at least something good came out of it. 126 Union Street, Carroll Gardens West.

Best highway to gout
Fette Sau
With a name that’s German for “fat pig,” it seems only fitting that TONY’s salute to culinary hedonism goes to Billyburg’s premier ’cue spot. Locals and destination gluttons throw caloric caution to the wind at the cafeteria-like food station, where a simple flick of the index finger can result in piles of grilled pastrami, ribs with meat that clings tenuously to the bone, and heart-stopping sides such as baked beans with burnt ends and monstrous sour pickles. (All washed down with a nice jug of Kelso lager.) The place can get crowded, so mind your neighbor’s toes—especially the swollen ones. 354 Metropolitan Avenue, Williamsburg.

Eat Out Awards 2008 [TONY]
Photos, clockwise from top left: Fette Sau by noneck; Radegast by ultraclay; Tabac by Matt MacDonald; Alchemy by scaredy_kat.




Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.brownstoner.com/mte/mt-tb.cgi/4605

Comments

Alchemy? feh - I don't get what the big deal is all about. The food was OK - not great, not bad, average. The beer selection was lacking. I wish someone could essplain to me the allure of the gastropub.... on an unrelated note, the braised pork belly app at Dressler is deee-lectible. the reduction sauce is soo good I could do shots of it. 'nuff said

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 9:57 AM

I went to Fette Sau with the wife and kids a couple of weeks ago and loved it. The BBQ was definiteiyl a little pricey I thought though. Good beer and good atmosphere though.

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 9:58 AM

Very glad to see Alchemy listed. It's one of the few restaurants serving very generous fresh servings of salads. The fried calamari is excellent - very tender, and the Duck Cassoulet is as good as dishes I've had in France. I do agree that the beer menu is limited as is the wine list.

Posted by: Brooklynnative at April 21, 2008 10:28 AM

agree with 9:57. dressler is exponentially better than alchemy.

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 10:31 AM

Dressler is great, but not new. Sidecar (a newbie) has better nosh than Alchemy.

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 10:34 AM

I loved Alchemy, We sat outside just after the opened and enjoyed a almost perfect steak!

I have not tried any of the others to compare against though! I have heard Elementi could rival Al Di La but is hard for me to believe.

Posted by: Pragonetti at April 21, 2008 10:57 AM

Although Tabac is open late and there is lots of outside seating, is there anything really good about the food?
Ever had the pork chop or hanger steak at cafe luluc? Tell me the steak is better at Tabac. I dare you.

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 11:34 AM

The food at Bar Tabac is very mediocre.

I really can't fathom why they would be included on any list. Cutsie french bistros are a dime a dozen in this city.

Posted by: Polemicist at April 21, 2008 12:30 PM

Sorry but I wouldnt put alchemy in the same league as the spotted pig. As far as I know they don't brew their own beer, I also wasnt that crazy about the food either, which is kind of uninventive (what, no offal?)

Cutsie french bistros are a dime a dozen on smith St alone...

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 12:48 PM

Tabac is great if you want your hair and clothes to smell like steak for week after you leave. I always feel like I need to shower before I can sleep after that place.

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 2:34 PM

Tabac food is indedible and the service is terrible.

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 3:20 PM

Bar Tabac may have ok ambiance, but it is EASILY the worst french restaurant in the area. And that's saying a lot considering we have: Quercy, Robin des Bois, Patois, Provence, Luluc, Pitstop, Jolie, and at least a couple others all within a ten minute walk of one another.

What a complete Joke.

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 4:53 PM

oh please, as if these TONY dimwits had any clue whatsoever. i don't know any of these joints, but one thing is dead certain, TONY is less of an authority on life in the outer boroughs than my grandmother. and she's dead and never set foot onto anyplace outside of italy...

Posted by: guest at April 21, 2008 10:09 PM

Ok, so it's not just me - Alchemy is pretty bland. I don't think most people can appreciate a place based on food, so they go by ambiance, affordability and - this is of course the most important criteria - whether and how quickly they got their free glass of water.

Posted by: guest at April 22, 2008 9:35 AM

I guess they just didn't take the food into account?

Posted by: guest at April 22, 2008 10:25 PM

tabac=nothin' special
alchemy=worse

gimme beast, al di la, geido, sidecare, and the defunct sorrel (weather up makes up for that sorrel loss...waiting for franklin park to rock my world: dose anyone have a scoop on that yet??)

Posted by: guest at April 23, 2008 1:58 AM

Post a comment

Please be patient while your comment is published. It may take a moment.

Latest Restaurant Additions