House of the Day: 591 Putnam Avenue

At first glance, we were pretty excited to see this detail-laden brownstone listed for only $650,000 $549,00. Then reality set in. For the longterm owner who's up for a major project, this still is probably one of the cheapest ways to get their hands on an old brownstone. For someone who's looking at this with the unemotional detachment of an investor, you have to wonder whether you want to be paying a million bucks when all's said and done for a house in this location. How does that stack up to recent comparables in the immediate vicinity? Update: The price must've just been cut. At $549,000 it certainly does look interesting.
591 Putnam Avenue [Corcoran] GMAP P*Shark
18 Comments
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 12:23 PM
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 12:26 PM
I've driven by this property but have not looked in. I'm more interested living closer to the edge of Clinton Hill (kid in elementary there) and wondering what anyone knows about the market closer to the Franklin C stop? Is the market stable or could it still decrease more?
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 1:36 PM
Look at the floor in the picture with the peely ceiling. Is that a common pattern? It's beautiful.
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 1:48 PM
The price cut is more interesting than the price itself.
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 1:49 PM
I don't think this is a good deal in this location. A business partner of mine has a building in the area a couple of blocks over at Tompkins (corner brick bldg)-closer to the Clinton hill and he is having trouble selling at 750-800K-which they say is market. It has been on the market for almost a year. It needs a full reno. No serious inquiries even for less.
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 2:39 PM
full reno for 750 is market? hmmm...
By Hal on November 27, 2006 3:19 PM
The condition of that ceiling suggests there may a problem with the roof.
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 4:00 PM
This house will be a good buy for someone who wants to live in their home and not flip the house (i.e.. anon 1:49). I think we all lose track of the fact that there are people who want to buy a home that they will stay in for a good 20-30 years.....
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 4:22 PM
anon 1:49: What size is your business partner's building and where is it located exactly? And who says $750k-$800k is market? And how have this property been marketed (fsbo, with sign in the window?)? Is there a broker involved in this?
These, admittedly, are a lot of questions, but if your statement has any relevance, then it begs these questions.
By ANONERS on November 27, 2006 4:56 PM
The ceiling shown in poor condition is on the ground floor. You can tell by the view out the windows and the bars there. Whatever the deal is with this ceiling, it's not because of a roof issue.
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 4:59 PM
19 Verona Place, a 4 story closer to Clinton Hill, just sold for $820k after a bidding war. The guy is gutting it. I think it's a flip or he's making condos.
By pc on November 27, 2006 9:09 PM
My friend lives next door to that house. Verona place. She said its been on the market for over a year. Tend to think that there's alot of internal problems.....
PC
By Anonymous on November 27, 2006 10:14 PM
This thread concerns 591 Putnam, not Verona Place. It (591 Putnam Street) looks like a good deal for someone who is comfortable with living in the neighborhood. I am not that familiar with this immediate area. Anyone has any meaningful details regarding the area?
By Anonymous on November 28, 2006 7:55 AM
9:09pm, Verona Place sat on the market for a long time because they weren't really marketing it. I happened to see the open house because I passed by one day. They were asking $775k and I think it was on craigslist/open house for 2 weeks. Other than that, one really wouldn't have known it was for sale. The house seemed sturdy. Anyway, I think that's an indication of the market in that area.
By Anon on November 28, 2006 11:29 AM
Was recently involved in bidding on a similar sized house a short block away from this one. It was in nice shape with lots of details - not more than $25K of work necessary.
We were in the low $700s and were outbid. So I would say this would be worth ~$750 in the current market fixed up nicely. So if the renovation could be done for less than $250K, then this might not be such a bad deal. Anyone know the address. Is it across from the old Armory?
By Anonymous on November 28, 2006 12:36 PM
It is directly across from the old Armory and right next to an abandoned building. The Corcoran photos of course don't show the abandoned building it is attached to.
By anon on November 30, 2006 12:01 PM
Um abandoned buildings. Plural. One on either side. I think it has great potential but every ceiling corner I tapped at sent rubble pouring down and at least one wall has real mildew.
By Brian D on November 30, 2006 1:18 PM
Well the exterior of the Brownstone seems in pretty decent condition. As for the neighborhood itself it is not that bad. Actually the area itself is building up. If the interior of the Brownstone is in half decent shape then i would say it is a nice buy. I am almost sure that work must be done but how much is the big question????
Anyone who would purchase this Brownstone could make nice revenue by renting it out. But again its how much work that needs to be done to the home. haggle with the price get the buyer to drop it to 500.000 even then i say go for it
Post a comment
Please be patient while your comment is published. It may take a moment.

if its priced at 549 its a good investment. if you're looking to get rental income from it you'll probably do a cheap reno anyway and it will still be worth if if there's no serious foundation, electrical or roofing problems.