Not everybody is profiting off the Downtown Brooklyn boom, according to a recent report. Families United for Racial and Economic Equality (FUREE) and the Urban Justice Center conducted surveys of 61 small businesses in Downtown Brooklyn over the past year and found 35 have since moved or gone under. Many of the closures were attributed to four large projects &mdash City Point, Al Laboz’s planned Willoughby West tower, Stahl Real Estate’s 50-story office tower, and the planned Willoughby Square Park &mdash and the decrease in daytime business as office towers were emptied for residential development. Three-quarters of the owners surveyed are immigrants, 64 percent non-white, and 23 percent women.

The report, “Out of Business,” points out that Fulton Mall was already one of the city’s most successful retail corridors with 100,000 daily shoppers and $100 million in annual sales. In fact, a prominent local broker explained to us that Fulton Mall’s retail space is so lucrative that landlords actually removed stairwells and elevators in many of the buildings to create more ground-floor space, which now rents at between $150 and $300 per square foot (we were wondering why all the unsightly boarded-up windows). He said residential and low-end office tenants who would have rented out the upper levels were more troublesome and less lucrative, so landlords simply boarded up the windows and stopped maintaining those floors. FUREE co-director Ilana Berger suggested landlords re-open that less expensive space to small business owners, many who had already been paying prime ground-floor rates, as one way to maintain Fulton Mall’s diversity. But she acknowledged that after decades of neglect, renovation would be costly. Berger said she also tried to meet with the City Point developers to help secure space for displaced and aspiring small businesses owners in the tower’s 500,000 square feet of planned retail, but was met with disinterest. Click through for stories on some of the businesses profiled in the report, and the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership’s response…

Alas, the report alludes, the new residents and office tenants the city hopes to attract don’t generally shop at the same book and apparel stores; they don’t get their hair and nails done at the same places; and they want a different crop of restaurants. And the landlords (only five of the entrepreneurs surveyed owned their store or building) want to cash in on the lucrative 2004 Downtown Brooklyn re-zoning, but in order to build towers, the existing business owners had to be kicked out. But will they be invited back?

Joe Chan, president of the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership, a public-private agency, responded with a statement: “Downtown Brooklyn is one of the fastest growing urban centers in America. The redevelopment activity in the area brings with it jobs and a permanently enhanced local economy. The Downtown Brooklyn Partnership with its BID partners work to connect small business owners with available resources and appropriate service providers.”

According to the report, many small business owners weren’t offered this assistance. Berger said the city could create a Business Relocation Assistance Corporation for Downtown Brooklyn like they have in Williamsburg-Greenpoint and other parts of the city. Displaced small businesses are provided grants that help with relocation costs such as moving heavy equipment; hiring lawyers, architects and contractors; and other costs associated with signing a new lease. Otherwise, relocation assistance is on the onus of landlords, isn’t always honored, and often involves lawyers. Here are a few businesses profiled:

• Gallery Religious Supplies owner Maisha Morales bought the business around 2001 when it was still at Albee Square Mall, and increased its daily earnings from $100 to $2,500 by 2006, according to the report. In in effort to sign a 20-year lease under previous owner Thor Equities, she spent $15,000 on lawyers, architects and contractors, then was served a nine-day eviction notice when rights to develop the building were awarded to the new owners, MacFarlane Partners and Acadia Realty Trust. She had to spend $85,000 to move and now pays three times her former rent for space on Willoughby Street.
• A & B Books owner Eric Gift, at one time the largest distributor of African American literature in the country with three stores in the Downtown Brooklyn area, may have to close his last location on Duffield Street, in the footprint of the planned Willoughby Square Park, if the city moves forward with seizing the property via eminent domain. The Lawrence Street and Atlantic Avenue locations closed down due to lack of business because of ongoing construction and changing demographics, according to the report. They first opened in 1989.
• Lawrence Street Wigs and Hats owners Joyce and Jee Kiehm ran a thriving business since 1986 by making customized wigs. They were forced out of 141 Lawrence Street because the new owner of their building, Stahl Real Estate, wants to build a 50-story tower, according to the report.
• Bagel Guys, at 102 Willoughby across from MetroTech, ran a thriving business until the Verizon building was sold and many Chase workers were relocated to New Jersey, but stuck around hoping the new BellTel residents would boost business again, according to the report. Despite being on a month-to-month lease since 2005, owner Jeff Garguilo bought out his partners with the understanding that his business would be safe for at least the next five years, then was served with a 60-day eviction notice once his landlord decided to redevelop the property. He is unemployed and unable to find affordable space within the vicinity, but is still looking.

The questions of the day are: What responsibility does the city have to ensure that these small business owners don’t fall into financial ruin in the process? And is there going to be a higher demand for the new businesses coming in than the ones already there, considering what’s available in surrounding retail corridors?

DoBro’s Average Household Income to Double? [Brownstoner]
Massive Bridge Street Tower In The Works? [Brownstoner]
Albee Square Mall Clears Out [Brooklyn Eagle]
Much of Downtown Brooklyn Is Going Out of Business [Brooklyn Eagle]

The study area: