Blogger A Brooklyn Life stumbles across 11 2nd Place three months after we did and comes to the same conclusion we did: The building’s a little out of scale but not half-bad:

I kinda like it. The stone matches well with many area buildings and the very expensive-looking and Frank Lloyd-esque windows add a nice touch. I’m not saying there isn’t room in the neighborhood code for a height limit, but height limits certainly don’t stop monstrosities.

Check out the rest of the post to see why A Brooklyn Life thinks maybe we should have height minimums too!
What’s Ugly? [A Brooklyn Life]
Stumbling Across 11 Second Place [Brownstoner]