header.jpg


about

  • This blog will document the renovation and conversion of the Broken Angel building in Clinton Hill by its creator Arthur Wood and local developer Shahn Andersen.

    © Brownstoner Media 2006

Recent Entries

Categories

Archives





« Articles About Broken Angel | Main | Rolling The Ball »

February 8, 2007

Arthur Fought The Law, And The Law Lost

arthur_smiles.jpg

Ever since the New York Times prematurely announced that Arthur and I had come to an agreement to develop Broken Angel, a number of people have questioned my sanity for taking on the project. Most of those people are business acquaintances of mine whose only knowledge of Arthur are photos they have seen of Broken Angel and anecdotes they have heard of something outlandish he said in a newspaper article or in a film. While I think being called eccentric is one of the highest compliments one could get, Arthur bristles at the suggestion that he is anything other than just more sane than the most people.

Arthur had a chance to prove his sanity in court yesterday. In October he was taken from his home in handcuffs and arrested for violating a vacate order from the Department of Buildings when they deemed his building to be unsafe and uninhabitable after a small fire. Arthur had chosen to represent himself in the criminal case, even though he faced a significant fine or jail time if found guilty of defying the order. I suggested that he get a public defender, or at the very least adjourn the case until he talked to an attorney about the best way to tackle it. Arthur insisted that he knew what he was doing. He attacked the charges against him on both a procedural and factual basis.

The vacate order stated on its front page that it was supposed to have an engineers report attached to it - it didn't. The arresting officers were supposed to have a warrant to arrest him - they didn't have one. They were also supposed to read him his miranda rights when he was being arrested - they didn't. One of the ECB violations used in the vacate order stated that the building was unsafe because it had no roof. Arthur refuted this with a printout from Google Earth showing the roof of the building, and presented photos of different parts of it taken by his son Chris.

I started calling Arthur's cell phone at 5:00 after I hadn't heard from him all day. Every time I dialed his number the phone just rang and rang. I was concerned. I had told him that even though the project could move forward if he did end up getting incarcerated for a short period of time, we could only get so far rebuilding his vision without him. Eventually, he picked up his house phone. "I didn't take my cell phone to court", he said, "And the judge threw out the case against me because they were wrong and I was right". Saner words could not be spoken.

-Shahn

Posted by broken angel at February 8, 2007 12:34 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.brownstoner.com/mte/mt-tb.cgi/499

Comments

Thank you for the update. I am so glad it ended well. What a mess & horrid ordeal he's been through. Best of luck on the wonderful project ahead!

Posted by: Anonymous at February 9, 2007 8:37 AM

Im glad they threw out the case b/c no one should be going to jail for this. (Doesn't the gov't have better uses for its courts and money?)

That said, I don't think the underlying issue of safety has been addressed. Is this dwelling safe?

I dont really care about code as I think the laws regarding code have more to do with a good plumbing and electrical product lobby than safety. But there are certain things that city has to protect the population from.

Provided its a safe place to inhabit...good for the both of you. Can't wait to see the progress.

Posted by: Anonymous at February 9, 2007 9:21 AM

I've always thought that Broken Angel and its creators were special, from the first time I saw it over twenty years ago, as a newcomer to Brooklyn. I used to shop for vintage furniture in the Salvation Army shop across the street, being a starving creative type myself. (they used to have great antiques for nothing, sigh.) I always wondered who owned it, and what was going on there, and as Clinton Hill gentrified over the years, I was always glad to see that this building stood tall, and was never taken over by loft loving developers, or torn down for Fedders houses.

I am very glad that Mr. Woods is a savvy and wise man, as well as a uniquely visionary and eccentric artist. A society is measured by the creative people who make all kinds of art, music and beauty, not just by the moneymakers and dealsmiths. I don't think that makes creative people above the law, but I do think that creativity sometimes needs special help to nourish and protect it. It seems suspicious to me that a tremendously large and very visible building like Broken Angel was invisible to DOB all these years, and only now that the property values have risen to the sky, do they come down on the Woods' like they never seem to come down on local slumlords whose negligence puts hundreds of people, including the very young, old and disabled, in dire peril.

I applaud the patnership of the Woods' and Shahn Andersen on this project. I don't know any of them personally, but in watching Shahn's progress on his own house, reading his (missed) blog, and seeing the care and research that he put into the restoration of his own home, I think that someone who cares about history, neighbors and neighborhood is a great choice for the Woods. I see no problem with him making money, why shouldn't he? He's taking the risks, taking the time, a ton of money, and will take most of the flack if one screw hits the ground and bounces in the wrong direction.

"Developer" has become a curse word in this city, because many of them seem to be greedy, law ignoring, law breaking, rich, tasteless bastards. That shouldn't be the case, and it will be interesting for us to be able to see what really goes on when one develops a building for multiple family living. Maybe we can all learn something from this, give a suggestion here and there, understand why certain things are done that we lay people don't like or understand. As a lover of architectural history, I am looking forward to seeing a ninteenth century factory turned into twenty-first century homes, and see it done with care and done well. I am eager to see the Woods' get a safe, warm new home for themselves, and see the sculptural masterpiece that is Broken Angel preserved and enlarged. I am also glad that space for other artists and creative people are in the plans, and hope that the Woods' and Shahn are able to do everything that they want to do with this large and unique space.

Buona fortuna.

Posted by: Crown Heights Proud at February 9, 2007 10:28 AM

I don't know why my first posts never have the Typekey logo, when I sign in, but that was me above, not my doppleganger.

Posted by: Crown Heights Proud [TypeKey Profile Page] at February 9, 2007 10:30 AM

Wow. What a story . Good luck to you guys

Posted by: eletricgreek [TypeKey Profile Page] at February 9, 2007 10:45 AM

get him a lawyer to sue the city for false arrest!

Posted by: anon at February 9, 2007 10:46 AM

you rule!

Posted by: Tony Tone at February 9, 2007 11:40 AM

I am so excited! this neighbourhood is a vibrant and diverse place and this building has long been an asset. thanks shahn for letting it continue to be so.

Posted by: miss priss at February 9, 2007 2:32 PM

this news makes my heart all warm and fuzzy. we were all rooting for you arthur!

Posted by: doueg at February 9, 2007 2:38 PM

Wow...i was nervous there for a sec. I live right next door to the Broken Angel and the last thing I want is to see it torn down. There's a lot of new construction that's been happening on Quincy and Downing street in the last few months and when I walked outside this morning and saw the scaffolding up my girlfriend and I almost lost it. My car was parked in the way of the truck that was loading in the dumpster that would haul most of the debris away. I may have held up the construction for an extra day. I'm not sure who I spoke with, it may have been Shahn, but he was very nice and cordial...I kind of had a feeling that this person wasn't here to tear down The Broken Angel. A very happy ending to an uncertain day.
A real estate agent with a heart.
Joey LP.

Posted by: Joey LP. at February 9, 2007 11:53 PM

I love the building, too. But could Shahn or someone give us any idea how on earth it can be brought up to code adn still have its personality? As groovy as all that crazy stuff on top looks, it seems inconceivable to me that it could be shored up and condos added beneath it. Would love to hear even just a conceptual idea for the place. Thanks, and good luck!

Posted by: Bob999 at February 10, 2007 5:35 PM

This is going to be interesting.

Posted by: anon at February 10, 2007 6:28 PM

Great idea Bob999. I'll address that in the next posting.

Posted by: Shahn Andersen at February 11, 2007 9:02 AM

Hey! The blog is great! I'm definitely going to keep checking. I think its great that you are on this project Shahn. This is what happens when you mix an artist with a businessman. It should be magical.

Posted by: goo at February 12, 2007 12:44 AM

Where might one go to find a little background info on Broken Angel?

Posted by: Joe at February 12, 2007 2:39 PM